I've never heard anyone meow on guard (121.5 MHz), but I've mostly flown single-radio aircraft, so I can't really monitor guard, and I've head it's an east-coast thing, but I've never flown in the area.
It doesn't really violate any regulations, because the use of guard is guidance, not regulation, and even if someone's talking on guard below 10,000 ft, it's a broadcast, not a conversation, so it would't violate sterile cockpit policies.
That being said, the FAA can basically do whatever it wants, because they have the authority to prohibit any pilot or airline from operating an airplane, whenever they want, for any reason, because of a rule they wrote that "no person may operate an aircraft in a careless or reckless manner". There's no case law to keep their authority within constitutional limits (compared to, for example, the SEC v. Jarkesy) because a hobbyist isn't going to have the time or money to go through multiple meaningless internal appeals to be able to appeal to an independent court, and anyone who's livelihood depends on it isn't going to risk it.
I've never heard anyone meow on guard (121.5 MHz), but I've mostly flown single-radio aircraft, so I can't really monitor guard, and I've head it's an east-coast thing, but I've never flown in the area.
It doesn't really violate any regulations, because the use of guard is guidance, not regulation, and even if someone's talking on guard below 10,000 ft, it's a broadcast, not a conversation, so it would't violate sterile cockpit policies.
That being said, the FAA can basically do whatever it wants, because they have the authority to prohibit any pilot or airline from operating an airplane, whenever they want, for any reason, because of a rule they wrote that "no person may operate an aircraft in a careless or reckless manner". There's no case law to keep their authority within constitutional limits (compared to, for example, the SEC v. Jarkesy) because a hobbyist isn't going to have the time or money to go through multiple meaningless internal appeals to be able to appeal to an independent court, and anyone who's livelihood depends on it isn't going to risk it.
Fans of the movie Super Troopers, perhaps?
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0247745/quotes?item=qt0470809&r...
Thank you for flying with Furry Air!
Only essential conversations are permitted below 10k ft so hence air traffic control had to remind the pilots to be professional.
Don't therians have some rights? (I only gekker when I am taking photographs of people and they aren't smiling and boy does it work!)