This post did not go in the direction I expected. From the title I thought the post would explore how chemical reactions depend on the geometry of molecules and the distribution of electrons, but instead it delved into how chemical kinetics can be graphed geometrically.
Author here, i really think i needed to give this post a better title...
I was very aware of the ambiguity in the title re. geometry of molecules vs geometry of kinetics though, and I was trying to be a bit cheeky :) ! Maybe I took it too far
I was hoping for the topic of enzyme kinetics and the influence of the geometry of the active site :)
Enzymes are very good at positioning the sidechains in the active site to influence how the reaction proceeds. Mutations of these sidechains can change the kinetics, speeding up or slowing down the reaction.
I do not question the author's expertise, and I find the post very interesting; however, we really ought to stop mistaking the map for the territory. While drawing such analogies is certainly very useful and powerful, assuming that this represents reality is truly a stretch, as none of it can be proven.
Also I find it a bit pedantic on the "theory" word, giving me the impression that the author have forgotten that there is no theory before practicing, exploring or experimenting that's why it's called theory.
> there is no theory before practicing, exploring or experimenting that's why it's called theory.
Theory has meaning beyond the scientific method. The etymology is about contemplation and speculation. Taking the title as an implication of binary reasoning sounds like "mistaking the map for the territory". I take it as a simple premise of the contained body of text. It wouldn't make sense to write an article about geometry in chemistry with a title like "Everything is Actually Everything... It's Complicated".
On the contrary, I find that a core disservice of the industrialised education system is that it inherently hides such analogies by segmenting knowledge into discrete disciplines. Analogies are how we understand the patterns of the cosmos through language. I was never taught how interrelated everything is. I ofcourse heard statements that alluded to it, but nobody ever stated that biology or geology are ultimately just a branch or subfield of chemistry, which is itself essentially a subfield of physics, itself a subfield of math... all different resolutions of the cosmos... but all of it is based on philosophy, and our entire perception of reality is just an interpretation of a tiny sliver of what exists... and most of reality itself might never be observable to us; never practiced, explored, or experimented beyond our minds... Oh no, I've gone cross-eyed.
I agree with everything you've said and I suspect we think the same way. I know theory's etymology, but I believe the author used it as the common modern scientist use it do today: As if the world actually runs following the "laws" of science and it's just a matter of computing power, an infinite recurring rounding error; I reject this, I believe that maps are very useful, but they are not the thing and what you've described about how we explore reality with our senses is exactly what I think these people are missing when they talk about theory.
"This book deals with epiphenomenalism, which has to do with consciousness as a mere accessory of physiological processes whose presence or absence... makes no difference… whatever are you doing?!"
I read the post quickly but there are no analogies here. This is well-trod theory of chemical reaction networks in the well-mixed regime.
We’ve known many of the results for 50-100 years and the theories have been thoroughly tested. These techniques are widely used in chemistry and biology.
The post is mostly, if not entirely, textbook as in you can take almost any physical chemistry textbook (in the US this would be an 3rd year undergrad class) and get essentially the same overview.
I actually thought the coverage was pretty shallow. A hand wave at quantum mechanics but no discussion of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. No discussion of reaction intermediates or mechanisms. No discussion of the dynamics of diffusion and when the well-mixed regime breaks down. Everything assumed that concentrations were high enough to avoid stochastic chemical kinetics. All of this is also pretty well-trod.
Anyone wanting a more thorough treatment of the field would be advised to look other places, like Steinfeld’s _Chemical Kinetics and Dynamics_ as well as the vast literature on this topic.
Isn’t this vibe basically the sort of cross theorem abstract thinking that gets mathematicians lauded with rewards when they bridge multiple fields of study?
You should let the mathematicians and philosophers of mathematics know because they’ve been confused about the nature of mathematics for over a century now and here you were knowing the answer all along.
Noone is mistaking the map for the territory here. Tfa describes a model which absolutely makes predictions which can be empirically falsified. Far from “none of it can be proven”, in this case all of it can be proven quite easily: the model describes the concentration of compounds in certain chemical reactions so you go to a lab, get your bunsen burner out, do the reactions and measure what concentrations you actually get.
Really this is a very old idea, going back to Plato. Everything physical is reduced to an abstract form that exists outside the physical.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platonism
There's no experimentation either without a theory(+), possibly nascent in someone's mind, preferably described systematically in a lab notebook if the research is to go far.
(+) Here, I'm allowing theory to stretch broadly to cover all manner of guesses and hypotheses.
Nothing in math or science can be proven with 100% certainty as its all based on unproven axioms. The best we can do is create useful models that are internally consistent.
With maths, we can prove things with 100% certainty given then axioms. The axioms are not there to be proved or disproved; they are what _define the system_. We can choose different axioms, and have a different system.
With science, we can't prove anything 100% because it is based on observation, not axioms.
The axioms are not there to be proved or disproved; they are what _define the system_.
This is not correct. We have a notion of the natural numbers in our minds but axiomatizing this notion is elusive and impossible if one insists on a nice set of axioms.
Consider this. I claim it is not possible to prove that addition of natural numbers is commutative. I claim this because any system of axioms one proposes to use as the axioms for the natural numbers that does not prove that addition is commutative would be rejected. What this shows is that we believe addition is commutative regardless of what axioms we use.
The axioms do not define the system. Axioms are found to be acceptable if they describe the system accurately enough.
You are talking about mathematical models to things. Math itself, on the other hand, have a meaning outside of any models, and that part is build to be provable, from axioms that indeed define the roots
You're getting downvoted because math isn't based on unproven axioms as you say.
Rather, math is based entirely on arbitrarily chosen/defined axioms - and it's literally all about proving 100% congruence/certainty to the definitions given.
It's in applying math to reality where there isn't a 100% certainty, but that is the realm of science.
They aren't arbitrary; they're useful. If we imagine a different set of axioms also being useful, which we sometimes do, we try to figure out what follows from them as well.
The definition of an axiom includes the fact that its unproven. Münchhausen's Trilemma showed that its impossible to prove any truth with absolute certainty without eventually relying on an unprovable assumption.
> Münchhausen's Trilemma showed that its impossible to prove any truth with absolute certainty without eventually relying on an unprovable assumption.
Obviously not, because if it was true then it couldn't have shown it without eventually relying on an unprovable assumption.
Which gives us a hint as to why it's wrong. It's possible to yield a logical contradiction if you accept a false premise, and in so doing establish that you have a false premise. You can thereby prove A by disproving not-A.
In other words, we can defeat Baron Munchausen with Sherlock Holmes: "When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth."
You're applying epistemology to formal logic. Münchhausen's Trilemma applies to proving objective truth about reality, not internal consistency.
In math, an axiom isn't an "unproven assumption" hoping to be true—it's a stipulated rule of a formal system. You don't prove the rules of chess are "true"; you prove that if you accept the rules, a checkmate follows with 100% certainty. Math guarantees conditional certainty (If A, then B), while science tests whether A actually matches reality.
I don’t think you truly understand what an axiom is.
The fact that axioms are taken as given does not mean we haven’t really proved anything in math. We have unambiguously proven an enormous amount of statements. Whether or not those axioms reflect absolute truths of our universe is a separate question, and has no bearing on whether or not those statements are true in a universe that does.
We've proven that our knowledge is internally consistent given the axioms we've chosen. But we can't say we've proven anything about the actual universe since one of the axioms is that there is an objective reality outside of our sense experiences and no one can ever prove that. Another axiom is that the laws of physics have always and will always be the same everywhere in the universe. This is also not something we can prove.
If the foundation of a statement is unproven then the statement is ultimately unproven. Yet, we can prove that statements derived from axioms are true or not within the system we've defined.
> But we can't say we've proven anything about the actual universe
Which universe are you talking about ? If it's the physical universe then your concern is Physics and/or applied maths.
Pure math is concerned with a different universe - of rules and axioms / initial / boundary conditions.
A pure mathematician is more like a board game designer.
You come up with a set of rules and a board and then examine their consequences. Some board and rule combinations lead to interesting and intellectually gratifying game plays. A pure mathematician would delight in that regardless of whether it is applicable to our physical universe or not.
Pure mathematicians are interested in coming up with novel "board games" or uncovering interesting and perhaps non-obvious characteristics of the game that follows if some other mathematicians board and rules are followed.
>Another axiom is that the laws of physics have always and will always be the same everywhere in the universe. This is also not something we can prove.
Actually, this is not as interesting of a point that you think it is.
Science is known to change over time. Any observation that violates existing physics results in a new physics law, which again is a constant law that applies to the entire universe. So what you are doing here is mixing two things into one pot.
The learning based approach to finding a model of the world and the model of the world.
The other part is that having local physical laws that cannot be explained by local parameters in itself is pretty hard and by that I mean there are some laws that only make sense if they apply throughout the entire universe and become meaningless if even a single cubic millimeter proves to be an exception.
Local deviation ruins global stability. Most symmetry laws and conservation must hold throughout the entire universe otherwise there would be pockets of space that create infinite energy or matter which then ends up dominating the entire universe.
> Nothing in math or science can be proven with 100% certainty
We have plenty of statements in math that have been proven with 100% certainty. They are true, they are simply true with associated conditions. Those conditions may not accurately reflect our universe—in many cases we know for certainty that they do not—but they are true nonetheless.
As an example, we are certain of the truth of the Banach-Tarski theorem. Its conclusions are inapplicable and nonsensical in the physical world because objects in ℝ³ and objects existing in the spatial dimensions of our universe are not equivalent. This does not make it any less true.
Mathematical statements are true under a given set of conditions. Those conditions being a requirement of a given statement’s truth does not make it uncertain or less true.
Plenty in math has been proven with 100% certainty. Saying it hasn't been is unequivocally false. Having an "if x" condition before a "then y" conclusion does not make the conclusion any less unproven or any less true.
Yeah, one big difference between math and empirical science is the second is determined by experimental results and observations. It doesn't matter what we think the world should be like, nature determines that for us. See the failure of string theory to unify QM and GR despite it's appeal.
String theory does unify QM and GR. That is its appeal.
My understanding is that the math works, but it works in an incomprehensibly large number of different possible ways — all of which have extreme consequences, none of which can be reasonably tested.
It’s worse than that. I’m a big fan of string theory actually, but there’s a Very Large number of possible ways to compactify the extra dimensions, and any particular way will have its own observable physical constants and particles but as I understand, we don’t yet even know of one that actually reproduces the physics we observe in its entirety. We have configurations that reproduce the standard model, or cosmological constant, etc, but not all of them at the same time.
I worked in a lab where a geologist was taking soundings to understand the geometry of plate techtonics. Smart guy but needed a geek for the Sun server, so I got to ride along.
Anyway, lots of things are "actually geometry" but chemistry is kind of the one science that really does just reduce to QED first principles pretty cleanly. You don't hear a lot of talk about emergent chemical phenomena.
Arithmetic can be "actually geometry" if you're good with a compass and straight edge and the use of geometry to understand numbers is old.
Anyway, I'd say chemistry is actually physics and that may or not be actually math of any kind. At least in part, probably.
You might need to learn more chemistry then, if you think you there's no emergence, especially in reaction networks like op discussed.
As a physicist whose worked with chemists... I don't see the value in saying chemistry is just physics. And its not even that I fundamentally disagree, it just not a valuable statement.
It's kind of anachronistic too. Thermo was born out of the fuzzy interface of chemistry and physics. Is thermo/stat mech chemistry or physics? Obviously physics, but the last 30 years the coolest stat mech developments came largely from "chemists". For a given phenomena/set of phenomena, there is usually a "best" way to approach it, and that best way is increasingly not going to separate cleanly by department.
Since you're talking confidently about emergence, I take it you're familiar with "more is different"?
Chemistry is mostly atoms and electrons. An AMO physicist can't do much with a polymer, but the polymer scientist (usually chemistry, chem E, sometimes physics department) certainly use born-oppenheimer...
> You don't hear a lot of talk about emergent chemical phenomena.
What? All of chemistry is basically emergent. we do not for example have clean, reducible models of the details of why aufbau diagrams fill the way they do in the transition metals, it's very hand-wavey and extremely empirical. Why does iron freely access the +3 and +2 states in ferrocene? Like why are titanium [-2] and [+1] states even a thing at all. Why does zirconocene have just enough space to do an p-pi sigma bond in ziegler natta catalysis? What the fuck even with p-pi sigma bonds in the first place?
> chemistry is actually physics
You cannot throw a physicist at chemistry and expect insight or even understanding to come easily. The defining mentality and approach are just so different. So much so that probably the methodological approach should be a better definition of what constitutes chemistry vs physics.
It's always taught that oxidation states are essentially a book-keeping strategy, and so can lend to bizzare bottom lines in complex systems wherein assumptions of clean charge attribution are invalid or less valid. However, I think I get what you are trying to say: you cannot expect a molecular biologist enter an OT and perform a coronary bypass.
You know more about chemistry than me, but when I studied emergence it was considered a more transparent layer than, say, psychology. It was considered at least something worth questioning as recently as 2022. [1]
Anyway, no one outside of your specialty knows what you're talking about and so that is congruent with my "you don't hear much about" which I think you read as "does not exist." I don't know if there are emergent chemical phenomena, just that they are thrown around to mere mortals like me the way evolution or social behavior are. Or life itself.
This isn't about physicists and chemists, obviously or their praxis. It's about what is actually happening and if you can explain it solely using the tools of the underlying layer.
You have succeeded in out esotericking me, but I don't think anything I stated was incorrect.
How are you defining emergence? Because I've always thought of it as simple rules that compose creating completely counter-intuitive results, and man is there a lot of that in chemistry.
TBF that's because those rules are merely approximations of the actual rules and undergraduate chemistry essentially consists of learning a series of progressively less wrong theories over the course of several years. Emergence flows from real rules which in chemistry would seem to be QM. But we can't actually fully simulate (as opposed to grossly approximate) a QM system beyond two (or perhaps three?) atoms so ... yeah.
I'd argue that the rules are needed though, because at some point we have to partition reality and say "x works this way, but y works more like this." So there's definitely less vs more accurate models, but the more accurate ones can have unnecessary mental overhead that makes it difficult to keep track of other details. I'm currently studying chemistry right now, and I've come to appreciate the layering of models happening (lewis dot diagrams for non-important details, pi bond delocalization for a planar molecule, band gap for light frequency, etc).
Also QM simulation is not completely hopeless! I'm actually doing computational chemistry research, and we're able to do reasonable approximations for around 70 atoms with a method called Density Functional Theory (DFT). And recent developments with machine learning have further given rise to Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials (MLIPs) (not to be confused with something like AlphaFold). Essentially it uses a GNN to predict the forces on all the atoms based on the current atomic arrangement, and then the simulation will advance through time by integrating (e.g. adding) the forces.
Agreed on all counts, but also I don't think you're actually refuting anything I said?
Certainly the various theoretical frameworks are useful. I was merely pointing out that they aren't the relevant ruleset when it comes to discussing emergent phenomena.
The approximations you listed while interesting and impressive nonetheless remain approximations. I haven't kept up with the state of the art but the computational complexity of full QM is utterly absurd. Normally that wouldn't be of any particular interest but it becomes relevant since when we talk about emergence we typically refer to simple and easily applied rulesets such as the various well known cellular automata.
> Agreed on all counts, but also I don't think you're actually refuting anything I said?
Fair enough. I guess when you said "progressively less wrong theories" I was thinking that the wrong theories are still quite useful in the right contexts, but I can see that you feel the same :)
> But the computational complexity of full QM is utterly absurd.
It's always a good sign when your naive algorithm scales 6^N /s. Not exactly simple in the sense of cellular automata like you mentioned, lol. But yeah, it's kind of insane. I'm hoping that we can train MLIP models for specific cases though, like could we fine-tune an MLIP to handle biochemical reactions at normal temperatures? It won't account for more exotic chemical reactions, but it would still open the door to model enzymes and receptors better. I'm hoping to go into research for QC methods because of all the cool opportunities it would open up (though man I have a long ways to go to even understand the math behind it).
Alternatively, as an explosion of complexity required to succinctly describe and/or predict consequences in a layer above a comparatively simple one. A classic example being Conway’s game of life.
chemistry is stacked on physics, just like biology is stacked on chemistry. the thing to take home is that they are subsets. chemistry sits on a slice of physics, like whipped cream on pie, and biology is a cherry on top of the cream.
in a manner of speaking, chemists are ultra specialized physicists, and biologists in particular molecular biologists are ultra specialized chemists.
the whole thing is a stack that assembles higher organization from lower subunits, typically atoms, molecules, and aggregates.
That's not what I meant. There are emergent phenomena built on chemistry, but what's emergent at the level of chemistry itself that doesn't reduce to physics?
When I was in college anyway, it wasn't part of the discussion.
Everything reduces to physics, but the simple rules of physics give complicated results when scaled up. It isn’t possible the calculate the full quantum mechanics of even simple molecules. The heuristics that simplify things, the experimental exceptions, and the statistical reactions are chemistry.
While I don't have the chops to appreciate this post, it reminded me of this recent lecture by Raymond Goldstein where he goes into how the distribution of cells in simple multi-cellular organisms looks a lot like Voronoi tesselations.
Reading this, it seems they're using the term "geometry" in a more abstract sense. Pretty much you can turn a reaction's state into an abstract point, and then you can plot that reaction point over time. It becomes concrete again when they plot the path of the reaction's "coordinates" and you can visually see what happened with the reaction. It's quite elegant! Like you can see a system oscillate if it circles forever, or you can see it converge if it spirals inwards.
Geometry means the study of a space with some structure studied up to structure-preserving maps. We're most used to Euclidian/analytic geometry where the structure is a distance metric and the maps are isometries, but there are other sorts of geometry (eg differential geometry, algebraic geometry etc) and for each you get different structure and different morphisms.
All of natural science is (dynamical) geometry, since it is just a time-evolution semantics over the reals. (Since all bodies are just geometrical extensions in space and time).
Well met. It's all geometry either in real space or phase space. One may often distill the dynamics to a set of generalized coordinates or a combination of them, then the abstract plot in 2D or 3D (the limit of my imagination) will begin at a glance to demonstrate the essence of the experimental observations but now in a very 'shapely' manner.
Complex numbers are also just a geometrical construction, they're pairs of reals which define rotations off the number line.
Whether youve one, or two, reals -- the reals are the heart of the matter, which make the representations geometrical (over, say, algorithmic which would be grounded in the integers).
This is a great tutorial on imaginary numbers illustrating how complex numbers : integers :: integers : natural numbers (apologies for not figuring out how to use reals instead integers in that simile).
Note the meat of the tutorial is contained in the frames that you navigate with the arrows on some of the illustrations. It doesn't display well on mobile.
In EE, complex numbers can be used to represent phases in electrical currents. However, you don't need them per se. C (the complex numbers) can be found as a subfield in the field of 2x2 matrices over real numbers. So instead of a+bi, you can treat it as the 2x2 matrix (a -b) (b a) , however the complex number notation is a lot simpler to use.
Fwiw, there are quantum phenomena that have been experimentally observed macroscopically that have been proven to require C in a way that no real-valued set of operators or effective field theories can provide.
Do you have citations or information about that? My understanding is that you can use real numbers but it makes notation and calculations a lot uglier. So complex numbers aren't necessary per se. Physics Review Letters published an article showing that this is the case this June [1] and I doubt it would have been published in PRL if there was definitive proof that complex numbers are required.
What about the field that is the vector space R^2 equipped with multiplication (a, b) ⋅ (c, d) = (ac - bd, ad + bc)? (Or fields built from such a field?)
(The algebraic structure of C is required, but the imaginary part is not)
To be specific M_2x2(R), the 2x2 matrices over R, has a subfield that is isomorphic to C. So there's no way to distinguish that subfield from C since they're identical up to notation (e.g. a+bi -> (a -b) (b a). It's similar to how physics uses i,j,k as 3d basis vectors and math will often use e_1, e_2, e_3.
I think its a bit funny to use the matrix example. If a person exists who thinks a matrix which can never pop out as roots of polynomials in R[x] is more believable that 'i' ehich naturally emerges out of R[x] what does it say about the inner intuition?
Came here to write something similar. Fully agree. Geometry is essentially a framework through which we abstract and describe observable phenomena. At its core, science relies on observation and measurement, geometry gives us a way to formalize the relationships.
Just is doing a lot of work here. What breathes life into the math to make it real? How does cosmology and the arrow of time fit into this? Why does a measurement collapse the wave equation math? What real things do quantum fields represent?
Probably a lot of material science is understanding how the molecules are structured in various shapes, crystals, etc. For example, this video shows cool visualizations: What comes after lithium-ion batteries? - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=huMZI_7iZKA
Repulsion is approximately sterics is geometry. I'm not disagreeing with you really, but much of protein folding is literally geometry, see banavar's work for example. I think "sculpt" is in the title of the paper I'm thinking of
This post is only about a tiny part of Chemistry, probably only half of the topic covered in the fists two years of a degree in Chemistry in the university. Later there are like 3 more years, and you may add 5 more for a PhD, and then there comes the weird research stuff.
The article is interesting to understand some cases, but the title oversells the coverage of Chemistry by a lot.
For example, there is nothing about organic chemistry. Let's pick one at random: What is the difference between CH3-O-CH3 and CH3-CH2-OH? They have the same atoms, somewhat similar structure, but they are very different materials and have very different reactions.
I assure you this material isn't covered in at least the first two to three years in a typical US undergrad chemistry or chemical engineering program. Feinberg's work relies on graph theory and linear algebra, it's not a given that an undergrad in those majors studies either of them, or if they do, it might be a service course (e.g., math for chemical engineers) that trades depth for breadth and simplicity. Even for PhD specialists in chemical kinetics, I can think of several former colleagues that didn't study Feinberg's work at all.
A banana is made of protons, neutrons and electrons. A rock of the same weight is made of protons, neutrons and electrons. Approximately the same amount of protons, neutrons and electrons. [1]
If you call the difference of a banana and a rock just geometry, everything is just geometry.
[1] I'm almost sure that a rock has more neutrons than a banana of the same weight. I'm trying to find an example that balance the protons, neutrons and electrons...
After thinking for a while, I think that a Diamond and a crystal of Sodium Hydroxide of the same weight, have the same numbers of protons, neutrons and electrons. Better and/or more disimile examples are welcome.
You’re saying there’s no geometric differences in the molecules?
that’s as absurd as saying that is all there are. the difference in bonds do in fact cause that.
or should we not look at molecular modeling software and instead focus on something a little further from geometry, like… uh… reaction energies? Oh, wait, in that case…
It is both eyes and hands, you can selectively energize the kinetic energy of species at a certain resonance frequency.
Suppose A- + B- <=> C- + D-
Then you can push the balance to the left by transmitting the ion frequencies for C- and D-, or to the right by energizing A- and B- ion species. So you can actuate reaction coordinates.
Sweep wit a frequency or white noise to identify how much of what is currently present in your vat.
I recall Lewis structures from Chem AP in high school and the first three quarters of Chemistry at university, no O-Chem. I can agree with the argument.
A system, at least within the foundations of physics, is any open set considered worthwhile to study.
A dynamic system is a system considered in the context of some theory of physics that evolve in time, such as classical dynamics or electrodynamics.
A dynamical system is a submanifold of a jet bundle over the product space of some open set and a time manifold which is almost always R with the most common exception being S^1, typically written as J^1(R×M), considered with some regularity conditions that permit you to do analysis over any contour lines of your choosing in the dynamical system. Essentially, it's a rigorous way to study what happens when you mix arbitrary differential equations and arbitrary differentiable manifolds, such as in the phase spaces of any random IRL shit.
A "dynamical system" is mostly just a shared abstraction that's useful for theorizing on the behaviour of systems and their behaviour over time -- especially a common set of phenomena like chaos, etc.
System is too general and underspecified and dynamic system is unclearly specified because you done know whether it readily exposes the interfaces/frameworks that someone would use to theorize about dynamical systems.
The addition of the Latin-originating -al suffix to the Greek word dynamic was deliberately chosen in 1927 when dynamical systems where first widely accepted by mathematicians to be a useful way of framing things in order to specifically separate it from the dozen things in physics that already used the name dynamics, since the mathematicians looking to axiomatise the things we now call dynamical systems wanted to get physicists to stay away from it and let the math community keep it for themselves.
Back at that point in history there was a much fiercer rivalry between the two fields.
I was going to say "of course chemistry can be simplified into geometry, since chemistry literally becomes real world geometry in the real world", but I've realised that that misses nuance. Even early into the article, in "Chemical systems have surprising behaviours" it becomes pretty clear how such a sentence misses nuance (I'm not entirely sure oscilation between PH and other properties has an obvious real-world-geometry analogue, for example). So yeah pretty interesting article, thumbs up emoji
Suddenly, the web pages became 10x longer with 10x more images, images turned into interactive animations etc. Usually the goal for the content of a page, that has a "Conclusions" section at the end, is to provide enough evidence to support the conclusions. The size of such supportive evidence usually depends on the cognitive abilities and contextual presence of the audience and effort required for producing the content.
Conclusion: Based on the above, the 10x increase in the page content is hereby concluded to be due to the drastically reduced effort in producing the content.
"we would be forced to study complex chemical systems on a case-by-case basis, and each new case would be fraught with terrible analytical difficulties" - oddly we are entering an age to brute force this
This appears to be true quantum chemistry and quantum circuit simulation as well; Complex Grassmanian GrC geometry and Layer-Coded Plabic VRC-SPA Ansatz to solve the speed-accuracy barrier:
This post did not go in the direction I expected. From the title I thought the post would explore how chemical reactions depend on the geometry of molecules and the distribution of electrons, but instead it delved into how chemical kinetics can be graphed geometrically.
Author here, i really think i needed to give this post a better title...
I was very aware of the ambiguity in the title re. geometry of molecules vs geometry of kinetics though, and I was trying to be a bit cheeky :) ! Maybe I took it too far
Just call it Chemical Kinetics is Actually Geometry
Actually it's not geometry. It's maybe more like Dynamical Systems or continuum mechanics.
Actually PDEs can be represented as geometric objects using jet bundles. So there you go
I was hoping for the topic of enzyme kinetics and the influence of the geometry of the active site :)
Enzymes are very good at positioning the sidechains in the active site to influence how the reaction proceeds. Mutations of these sidechains can change the kinetics, speeding up or slowing down the reaction.
That's exactly what I expected as well for some reason.
So it’s geometry + electromagnetism
I do not question the author's expertise, and I find the post very interesting; however, we really ought to stop mistaking the map for the territory. While drawing such analogies is certainly very useful and powerful, assuming that this represents reality is truly a stretch, as none of it can be proven.
Also I find it a bit pedantic on the "theory" word, giving me the impression that the author have forgotten that there is no theory before practicing, exploring or experimenting that's why it's called theory.
> there is no theory before practicing, exploring or experimenting that's why it's called theory.
Theory has meaning beyond the scientific method. The etymology is about contemplation and speculation. Taking the title as an implication of binary reasoning sounds like "mistaking the map for the territory". I take it as a simple premise of the contained body of text. It wouldn't make sense to write an article about geometry in chemistry with a title like "Everything is Actually Everything... It's Complicated".
On the contrary, I find that a core disservice of the industrialised education system is that it inherently hides such analogies by segmenting knowledge into discrete disciplines. Analogies are how we understand the patterns of the cosmos through language. I was never taught how interrelated everything is. I ofcourse heard statements that alluded to it, but nobody ever stated that biology or geology are ultimately just a branch or subfield of chemistry, which is itself essentially a subfield of physics, itself a subfield of math... all different resolutions of the cosmos... but all of it is based on philosophy, and our entire perception of reality is just an interpretation of a tiny sliver of what exists... and most of reality itself might never be observable to us; never practiced, explored, or experimented beyond our minds... Oh no, I've gone cross-eyed.
I agree with everything you've said and I suspect we think the same way. I know theory's etymology, but I believe the author used it as the common modern scientist use it do today: As if the world actually runs following the "laws" of science and it's just a matter of computing power, an infinite recurring rounding error; I reject this, I believe that maps are very useful, but they are not the thing and what you've described about how we explore reality with our senses is exactly what I think these people are missing when they talk about theory.
"This book deals with epiphenomenalism, which has to do with consciousness as a mere accessory of physiological processes whose presence or absence... makes no difference… whatever are you doing?!"
This reads like the architect in The Matrix crossed with the asshole in the bar in Good Will Hunting.
I read the post quickly but there are no analogies here. This is well-trod theory of chemical reaction networks in the well-mixed regime.
We’ve known many of the results for 50-100 years and the theories have been thoroughly tested. These techniques are widely used in chemistry and biology.
The post is mostly, if not entirely, textbook as in you can take almost any physical chemistry textbook (in the US this would be an 3rd year undergrad class) and get essentially the same overview.
I actually thought the coverage was pretty shallow. A hand wave at quantum mechanics but no discussion of the Born-Oppenheimer approximation. No discussion of reaction intermediates or mechanisms. No discussion of the dynamics of diffusion and when the well-mixed regime breaks down. Everything assumed that concentrations were high enough to avoid stochastic chemical kinetics. All of this is also pretty well-trod.
Anyone wanting a more thorough treatment of the field would be advised to look other places, like Steinfeld’s _Chemical Kinetics and Dynamics_ as well as the vast literature on this topic.
Isn’t this vibe basically the sort of cross theorem abstract thinking that gets mathematicians lauded with rewards when they bridge multiple fields of study?
Sure but science isn't math
math and science are siblings both sired of logic, and stoicism, thus are derivatives of philosophy.
You should let the mathematicians and philosophers of mathematics know because they’ve been confused about the nature of mathematics for over a century now and here you were knowing the answer all along.
this is all very poetic but science is empirical while math is not
All of that pesky concern with reality beyond internal consistency sure is a PITA ha.
Noone is mistaking the map for the territory here. Tfa describes a model which absolutely makes predictions which can be empirically falsified. Far from “none of it can be proven”, in this case all of it can be proven quite easily: the model describes the concentration of compounds in certain chemical reactions so you go to a lab, get your bunsen burner out, do the reactions and measure what concentrations you actually get.
Really this is a very old idea, going back to Plato. Everything physical is reduced to an abstract form that exists outside the physical. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Platonism
There's no experimentation either without a theory(+), possibly nascent in someone's mind, preferably described systematically in a lab notebook if the research is to go far.
(+) Here, I'm allowing theory to stretch broadly to cover all manner of guesses and hypotheses.
Pythagoras would like to have a word with you; the world made of math.
Nothing in math or science can be proven with 100% certainty as its all based on unproven axioms. The best we can do is create useful models that are internally consistent.
Maths and science are different beasts.
With maths, we can prove things with 100% certainty given then axioms. The axioms are not there to be proved or disproved; they are what _define the system_. We can choose different axioms, and have a different system.
With science, we can't prove anything 100% because it is based on observation, not axioms.
The axioms are not there to be proved or disproved; they are what _define the system_.
This is not correct. We have a notion of the natural numbers in our minds but axiomatizing this notion is elusive and impossible if one insists on a nice set of axioms.
Consider this. I claim it is not possible to prove that addition of natural numbers is commutative. I claim this because any system of axioms one proposes to use as the axioms for the natural numbers that does not prove that addition is commutative would be rejected. What this shows is that we believe addition is commutative regardless of what axioms we use.
The axioms do not define the system. Axioms are found to be acceptable if they describe the system accurately enough.
You are talking about mathematical models to things. Math itself, on the other hand, have a meaning outside of any models, and that part is build to be provable, from axioms that indeed define the roots
You're getting downvoted because math isn't based on unproven axioms as you say.
Rather, math is based entirely on arbitrarily chosen/defined axioms - and it's literally all about proving 100% congruence/certainty to the definitions given.
It's in applying math to reality where there isn't a 100% certainty, but that is the realm of science.
They aren't arbitrary; they're useful. If we imagine a different set of axioms also being useful, which we sometimes do, we try to figure out what follows from them as well.
In mathematics, "Arbitrary" means freely chosen, not useless or random.
The definition of an axiom includes the fact that its unproven. Münchhausen's Trilemma showed that its impossible to prove any truth with absolute certainty without eventually relying on an unprovable assumption.
> Münchhausen's Trilemma showed that its impossible to prove any truth with absolute certainty without eventually relying on an unprovable assumption.
Obviously not, because if it was true then it couldn't have shown it without eventually relying on an unprovable assumption.
Which gives us a hint as to why it's wrong. It's possible to yield a logical contradiction if you accept a false premise, and in so doing establish that you have a false premise. You can thereby prove A by disproving not-A.
In other words, we can defeat Baron Munchausen with Sherlock Holmes: "When you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth."
You're applying epistemology to formal logic. Münchhausen's Trilemma applies to proving objective truth about reality, not internal consistency.
In math, an axiom isn't an "unproven assumption" hoping to be true—it's a stipulated rule of a formal system. You don't prove the rules of chess are "true"; you prove that if you accept the rules, a checkmate follows with 100% certainty. Math guarantees conditional certainty (If A, then B), while science tests whether A actually matches reality.
I don’t think you truly understand what an axiom is.
The fact that axioms are taken as given does not mean we haven’t really proved anything in math. We have unambiguously proven an enormous amount of statements. Whether or not those axioms reflect absolute truths of our universe is a separate question, and has no bearing on whether or not those statements are true in a universe that does.
We've proven that our knowledge is internally consistent given the axioms we've chosen. But we can't say we've proven anything about the actual universe since one of the axioms is that there is an objective reality outside of our sense experiences and no one can ever prove that. Another axiom is that the laws of physics have always and will always be the same everywhere in the universe. This is also not something we can prove.
If the foundation of a statement is unproven then the statement is ultimately unproven. Yet, we can prove that statements derived from axioms are true or not within the system we've defined.
> But we can't say we've proven anything about the actual universe
Which universe are you talking about ? If it's the physical universe then your concern is Physics and/or applied maths.
Pure math is concerned with a different universe - of rules and axioms / initial / boundary conditions.
A pure mathematician is more like a board game designer.
You come up with a set of rules and a board and then examine their consequences. Some board and rule combinations lead to interesting and intellectually gratifying game plays. A pure mathematician would delight in that regardless of whether it is applicable to our physical universe or not.
Pure mathematicians are interested in coming up with novel "board games" or uncovering interesting and perhaps non-obvious characteristics of the game that follows if some other mathematicians board and rules are followed.
>Another axiom is that the laws of physics have always and will always be the same everywhere in the universe. This is also not something we can prove.
Actually, this is not as interesting of a point that you think it is.
Science is known to change over time. Any observation that violates existing physics results in a new physics law, which again is a constant law that applies to the entire universe. So what you are doing here is mixing two things into one pot.
The learning based approach to finding a model of the world and the model of the world.
The other part is that having local physical laws that cannot be explained by local parameters in itself is pretty hard and by that I mean there are some laws that only make sense if they apply throughout the entire universe and become meaningless if even a single cubic millimeter proves to be an exception.
Local deviation ruins global stability. Most symmetry laws and conservation must hold throughout the entire universe otherwise there would be pockets of space that create infinite energy or matter which then ends up dominating the entire universe.
Your original statement was
> Nothing in math or science can be proven with 100% certainty
We have plenty of statements in math that have been proven with 100% certainty. They are true, they are simply true with associated conditions. Those conditions may not accurately reflect our universe—in many cases we know for certainty that they do not—but they are true nonetheless.
As an example, we are certain of the truth of the Banach-Tarski theorem. Its conclusions are inapplicable and nonsensical in the physical world because objects in ℝ³ and objects existing in the spatial dimensions of our universe are not equivalent. This does not make it any less true.
Mathematical statements are true under a given set of conditions. Those conditions being a requirement of a given statement’s truth does not make it uncertain or less true.
We're both saying the same thing my friend.
If we are, you're saying it poorly.
Plenty in math has been proven with 100% certainty. Saying it hasn't been is unequivocally false. Having an "if x" condition before a "then y" conclusion does not make the conclusion any less unproven or any less true.
Yeah, one big difference between math and empirical science is the second is determined by experimental results and observations. It doesn't matter what we think the world should be like, nature determines that for us. See the failure of string theory to unify QM and GR despite it's appeal.
String theory does unify QM and GR. That is its appeal.
My understanding is that the math works, but it works in an incomprehensibly large number of different possible ways — all of which have extreme consequences, none of which can be reasonably tested.
It’s worse than that. I’m a big fan of string theory actually, but there’s a Very Large number of possible ways to compactify the extra dimensions, and any particular way will have its own observable physical constants and particles but as I understand, we don’t yet even know of one that actually reproduces the physics we observe in its entirety. We have configurations that reproduce the standard model, or cosmological constant, etc, but not all of them at the same time.
I worked in a lab where a geologist was taking soundings to understand the geometry of plate techtonics. Smart guy but needed a geek for the Sun server, so I got to ride along.
Anyway, lots of things are "actually geometry" but chemistry is kind of the one science that really does just reduce to QED first principles pretty cleanly. You don't hear a lot of talk about emergent chemical phenomena.
Arithmetic can be "actually geometry" if you're good with a compass and straight edge and the use of geometry to understand numbers is old.
Anyway, I'd say chemistry is actually physics and that may or not be actually math of any kind. At least in part, probably.
You might need to learn more chemistry then, if you think you there's no emergence, especially in reaction networks like op discussed.
As a physicist whose worked with chemists... I don't see the value in saying chemistry is just physics. And its not even that I fundamentally disagree, it just not a valuable statement.
It's kind of anachronistic too. Thermo was born out of the fuzzy interface of chemistry and physics. Is thermo/stat mech chemistry or physics? Obviously physics, but the last 30 years the coolest stat mech developments came largely from "chemists". For a given phenomena/set of phenomena, there is usually a "best" way to approach it, and that best way is increasingly not going to separate cleanly by department.
Since you're talking confidently about emergence, I take it you're familiar with "more is different"?
Chemistry is mostly atoms and electrons. An AMO physicist can't do much with a polymer, but the polymer scientist (usually chemistry, chem E, sometimes physics department) certainly use born-oppenheimer...
> You don't hear a lot of talk about emergent chemical phenomena.
What? All of chemistry is basically emergent. we do not for example have clean, reducible models of the details of why aufbau diagrams fill the way they do in the transition metals, it's very hand-wavey and extremely empirical. Why does iron freely access the +3 and +2 states in ferrocene? Like why are titanium [-2] and [+1] states even a thing at all. Why does zirconocene have just enough space to do an p-pi sigma bond in ziegler natta catalysis? What the fuck even with p-pi sigma bonds in the first place?
> chemistry is actually physics
You cannot throw a physicist at chemistry and expect insight or even understanding to come easily. The defining mentality and approach are just so different. So much so that probably the methodological approach should be a better definition of what constitutes chemistry vs physics.
It's always taught that oxidation states are essentially a book-keeping strategy, and so can lend to bizzare bottom lines in complex systems wherein assumptions of clean charge attribution are invalid or less valid. However, I think I get what you are trying to say: you cannot expect a molecular biologist enter an OT and perform a coronary bypass.
You know more about chemistry than me, but when I studied emergence it was considered a more transparent layer than, say, psychology. It was considered at least something worth questioning as recently as 2022. [1]
Anyway, no one outside of your specialty knows what you're talking about and so that is congruent with my "you don't hear much about" which I think you read as "does not exist." I don't know if there are emergent chemical phenomena, just that they are thrown around to mere mortals like me the way evolution or social behavior are. Or life itself.
This isn't about physicists and chemists, obviously or their praxis. It's about what is actually happening and if you can explain it solely using the tools of the underlying layer.
You have succeeded in out esotericking me, but I don't think anything I stated was incorrect.
[1] "Nevertheless, the matter of emergence in chemistry is far from settled." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9814932/ (2022)
How are you defining emergence? Because I've always thought of it as simple rules that compose creating completely counter-intuitive results, and man is there a lot of that in chemistry.
Indeed, the maddening thing about chemistry for me was having to remember all of the exceptions to the rules. I stuck with physics instead.
TBF that's because those rules are merely approximations of the actual rules and undergraduate chemistry essentially consists of learning a series of progressively less wrong theories over the course of several years. Emergence flows from real rules which in chemistry would seem to be QM. But we can't actually fully simulate (as opposed to grossly approximate) a QM system beyond two (or perhaps three?) atoms so ... yeah.
I'd argue that the rules are needed though, because at some point we have to partition reality and say "x works this way, but y works more like this." So there's definitely less vs more accurate models, but the more accurate ones can have unnecessary mental overhead that makes it difficult to keep track of other details. I'm currently studying chemistry right now, and I've come to appreciate the layering of models happening (lewis dot diagrams for non-important details, pi bond delocalization for a planar molecule, band gap for light frequency, etc).
Also QM simulation is not completely hopeless! I'm actually doing computational chemistry research, and we're able to do reasonable approximations for around 70 atoms with a method called Density Functional Theory (DFT). And recent developments with machine learning have further given rise to Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials (MLIPs) (not to be confused with something like AlphaFold). Essentially it uses a GNN to predict the forces on all the atoms based on the current atomic arrangement, and then the simulation will advance through time by integrating (e.g. adding) the forces.
Agreed on all counts, but also I don't think you're actually refuting anything I said?
Certainly the various theoretical frameworks are useful. I was merely pointing out that they aren't the relevant ruleset when it comes to discussing emergent phenomena.
The approximations you listed while interesting and impressive nonetheless remain approximations. I haven't kept up with the state of the art but the computational complexity of full QM is utterly absurd. Normally that wouldn't be of any particular interest but it becomes relevant since when we talk about emergence we typically refer to simple and easily applied rulesets such as the various well known cellular automata.
> Agreed on all counts, but also I don't think you're actually refuting anything I said?
Fair enough. I guess when you said "progressively less wrong theories" I was thinking that the wrong theories are still quite useful in the right contexts, but I can see that you feel the same :)
> But the computational complexity of full QM is utterly absurd.
It's always a good sign when your naive algorithm scales 6^N /s. Not exactly simple in the sense of cellular automata like you mentioned, lol. But yeah, it's kind of insane. I'm hoping that we can train MLIP models for specific cases though, like could we fine-tune an MLIP to handle biochemical reactions at normal temperatures? It won't account for more exotic chemical reactions, but it would still open the door to model enzymes and receptors better. I'm hoping to go into research for QC methods because of all the cool opportunities it would open up (though man I have a long ways to go to even understand the math behind it).
Alternatively, as an explosion of complexity required to succinctly describe and/or predict consequences in a layer above a comparatively simple one. A classic example being Conway’s game of life.
>> You don't hear a lot of..
>> At least in part, probably.
> You have succeeded in out esotericking me, but I don't think anything I stated was incorrect.
I agree, it's very hard to disprove loose claims. It's a good strategy for not being disproved.
I don't really understand the opinion piece you linked to though, which seems mainly philosophical. Can you explain it to me?
QED = ???
Quantum Electrodynamics? quod erat demonstrandum?
in either case, not sure exactly what you're claiming. biochemistry emerges from chemistry...RNA world, etc..
Quite Easily Done.
chemistry is stacked on physics, just like biology is stacked on chemistry. the thing to take home is that they are subsets. chemistry sits on a slice of physics, like whipped cream on pie, and biology is a cherry on top of the cream.
in a manner of speaking, chemists are ultra specialized physicists, and biologists in particular molecular biologists are ultra specialized chemists.
the whole thing is a stack that assembles higher organization from lower subunits, typically atoms, molecules, and aggregates.
> You don't hear a lot of talk about emergent chemical phenomena.
To be fair, you absolutely do; it's just usually called something different. Like "biology".
That's not what I meant. There are emergent phenomena built on chemistry, but what's emergent at the level of chemistry itself that doesn't reduce to physics?
When I was in college anyway, it wasn't part of the discussion.
Everything reduces to physics, but the simple rules of physics give complicated results when scaled up. It isn’t possible the calculate the full quantum mechanics of even simple molecules. The heuristics that simplify things, the experimental exceptions, and the statistical reactions are chemistry.
Literally nothing at the level of chemistry - emergent or not - doesn't reduce to physics.
https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/435:_Purity / https://xkcd.com/435
(edit: although I think downvoting the question is a bit harsh; did I miss something?)
While I don't have the chops to appreciate this post, it reminded me of this recent lecture by Raymond Goldstein where he goes into how the distribution of cells in simple multi-cellular organisms looks a lot like Voronoi tesselations.
Here's a related paper from his group: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.11939
Reading this, it seems they're using the term "geometry" in a more abstract sense. Pretty much you can turn a reaction's state into an abstract point, and then you can plot that reaction point over time. It becomes concrete again when they plot the path of the reaction's "coordinates" and you can visually see what happened with the reaction. It's quite elegant! Like you can see a system oscillate if it circles forever, or you can see it converge if it spirals inwards.
Geometry means the study of a space with some structure studied up to structure-preserving maps. We're most used to Euclidian/analytic geometry where the structure is a distance metric and the maps are isometries, but there are other sorts of geometry (eg differential geometry, algebraic geometry etc) and for each you get different structure and different morphisms.
All of natural science is (dynamical) geometry, since it is just a time-evolution semantics over the reals. (Since all bodies are just geometrical extensions in space and time).
Well met. It's all geometry either in real space or phase space. One may often distill the dynamics to a set of generalized coordinates or a combination of them, then the abstract plot in 2D or 3D (the limit of my imagination) will begin at a glance to demonstrate the essence of the experimental observations but now in a very 'shapely' manner.
> just a time-evolution semantics over the reals.
I could be wrong but I remember my EE friends saying imaginary numbers show up in nature somewhere. That blew my mind so has stuck with me.
Complex numbers are also just a geometrical construction, they're pairs of reals which define rotations off the number line.
Whether youve one, or two, reals -- the reals are the heart of the matter, which make the representations geometrical (over, say, algorithmic which would be grounded in the integers).
This is a great tutorial on imaginary numbers illustrating how complex numbers : integers :: integers : natural numbers (apologies for not figuring out how to use reals instead integers in that simile).
https://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/
Note the meat of the tutorial is contained in the frames that you navigate with the arrows on some of the illustrations. It doesn't display well on mobile.
In EE, complex numbers can be used to represent phases in electrical currents. However, you don't need them per se. C (the complex numbers) can be found as a subfield in the field of 2x2 matrices over real numbers. So instead of a+bi, you can treat it as the 2x2 matrix (a -b) (b a) , however the complex number notation is a lot simpler to use.
Fwiw, there are quantum phenomena that have been experimentally observed macroscopically that have been proven to require C in a way that no real-valued set of operators or effective field theories can provide.
Do you have citations or information about that? My understanding is that you can use real numbers but it makes notation and calculations a lot uglier. So complex numbers aren't necessary per se. Physics Review Letters published an article showing that this is the case this June [1] and I doubt it would have been published in PRL if there was definitive proof that complex numbers are required.
[1] https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/4k13-sdjh
What about the field that is the vector space R^2 equipped with multiplication (a, b) ⋅ (c, d) = (ac - bd, ad + bc)? (Or fields built from such a field?)
(The algebraic structure of C is required, but the imaginary part is not)
To be specific M_2x2(R), the 2x2 matrices over R, has a subfield that is isomorphic to C. So there's no way to distinguish that subfield from C since they're identical up to notation (e.g. a+bi -> (a -b) (b a). It's similar to how physics uses i,j,k as 3d basis vectors and math will often use e_1, e_2, e_3.
This is how complex numbers were taught to me. The i thing just helps with making the book keeping easy.
I think its a bit funny to use the matrix example. If a person exists who thinks a matrix which can never pop out as roots of polynomials in R[x] is more believable that 'i' ehich naturally emerges out of R[x] what does it say about the inner intuition?
This is mostly because multiplication by i is a neat notation for a 90 degree rotation in a plane.
Pretty much every other physical use is also because i has a cyclic 4 periodic structure.
Came here to write something similar. Fully agree. Geometry is essentially a framework through which we abstract and describe observable phenomena. At its core, science relies on observation and measurement, geometry gives us a way to formalize the relationships.
I thought it was all Eigenvectors.
I thought it was all oscillators all the way down
Just is doing a lot of work here. What breathes life into the math to make it real? How does cosmology and the arrow of time fit into this? Why does a measurement collapse the wave equation math? What real things do quantum fields represent?
units and symmetric breaking
units = the semantics, so that "1" of something is a property of a particular extension in time and space (eg., of charge)
symmetry breaking = all the ways that the reals are carved up
> Why does a measurement collapse the wave equation math?
Weird fringes at the seams of the simulated world we are in. Lazy evaluation and limits in calculation precision/performance.
Probably a lot of material science is understanding how the molecules are structured in various shapes, crystals, etc. For example, this video shows cool visualizations: What comes after lithium-ion batteries? - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=huMZI_7iZKA
Proteins fold, thats also geometry.
Folding is more complicated than geometry because attraction and repulsion matter at a distance not just via direct contact.
Repulsion is approximately sterics is geometry. I'm not disagreeing with you really, but much of protein folding is literally geometry, see banavar's work for example. I think "sculpt" is in the title of the paper I'm thinking of
Folding involves momentum and the net impact of a large number of forces which keep changing through time.
Sterics is a vastly simplified model as atoms aren’t static. There’s a lot of real world behaviors that you don’t get from static models.
You may be surprised to find out that "distance" is also a concept found in... geometry.
Momentum however does not.
Thus the critical distinction between distance and at a distance.
You may be surprised to find out that "distance" doesn't always capture the intricacies of an atom's electron configuration.
I found the first reference very interesting:
https://www.buildacell.org/101
This post is only about a tiny part of Chemistry, probably only half of the topic covered in the fists two years of a degree in Chemistry in the university. Later there are like 3 more years, and you may add 5 more for a PhD, and then there comes the weird research stuff.
The article is interesting to understand some cases, but the title oversells the coverage of Chemistry by a lot.
For example, there is nothing about organic chemistry. Let's pick one at random: What is the difference between CH3-O-CH3 and CH3-CH2-OH? They have the same atoms, somewhat similar structure, but they are very different materials and have very different reactions.
I assure you this material isn't covered in at least the first two to three years in a typical US undergrad chemistry or chemical engineering program. Feinberg's work relies on graph theory and linear algebra, it's not a given that an undergrad in those majors studies either of them, or if they do, it might be a service course (e.g., math for chemical engineers) that trades depth for breadth and simplicity. Even for PhD specialists in chemical kinetics, I can think of several former colleagues that didn't study Feinberg's work at all.
The geometric arrangement would also differ. Meaningfully.
I get the sentiment but that’s a poor example.
A banana is made of protons, neutrons and electrons. A rock of the same weight is made of protons, neutrons and electrons. Approximately the same amount of protons, neutrons and electrons. [1]
If you call the difference of a banana and a rock just geometry, everything is just geometry.
---
Back to my example:
CH3-O-CH3 is a gas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dimethyl_ether
CH3-CH2-OH is a liquid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethanol
The difference is very slight advanced chemistry that is not geometry and is out of the scope of the article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_bond
---
[1] I'm almost sure that a rock has more neutrons than a banana of the same weight. I'm trying to find an example that balance the protons, neutrons and electrons...
After thinking for a while, I think that a Diamond and a crystal of Sodium Hydroxide of the same weight, have the same numbers of protons, neutrons and electrons. Better and/or more disimile examples are welcome.
You’re saying there’s no geometric differences in the molecules?
that’s as absurd as saying that is all there are. the difference in bonds do in fact cause that.
or should we not look at molecular modeling software and instead focus on something a little further from geometry, like… uh… reaction energies? Oh, wait, in that case…
Chemistry includes geometry, but its not JUST geometry. Its far more complex than that.
There is in fact also topology, and in some niches analysis.
> Unfortunately, if we experimented with such processes in a closed vat, it would be impossible to estimate these rate constants with any certainty.
Nonsense, check out FT-ICR
Fourier Transform Ion Cyclotron Resonance Spectroscopy
https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/sci/chemistry/research/oconnor/oco...
It is both eyes and hands, you can selectively energize the kinetic energy of species at a certain resonance frequency.
Suppose A- + B- <=> C- + D-
Then you can push the balance to the left by transmitting the ion frequencies for C- and D-, or to the right by energizing A- and B- ion species. So you can actuate reaction coordinates.
Sweep wit a frequency or white noise to identify how much of what is currently present in your vat.
This tool is both eyes and hands.
I recall Lewis structures from Chem AP in high school and the first three quarters of Chemistry at university, no O-Chem. I can agree with the argument.
(A physicist might say that the entire reality is actually geometry.)
as a geometer I say all of reality can be described in geometry
This was pretty neat. I didn't know oscillatory phenomena were so common in chemical reactions.
I think they called this "dynamical systems" when I was in school
What is the difference between a system, a dynamic system and a dynamical system?
A system, at least within the foundations of physics, is any open set considered worthwhile to study.
A dynamic system is a system considered in the context of some theory of physics that evolve in time, such as classical dynamics or electrodynamics.
A dynamical system is a submanifold of a jet bundle over the product space of some open set and a time manifold which is almost always R with the most common exception being S^1, typically written as J^1(R×M), considered with some regularity conditions that permit you to do analysis over any contour lines of your choosing in the dynamical system. Essentially, it's a rigorous way to study what happens when you mix arbitrary differential equations and arbitrary differentiable manifolds, such as in the phase spaces of any random IRL shit.
So a system doesn't change over time?
Every dynamic system and dynamical system is still a system.
System is the broadest definition that includes every category, the ones with time, the ones without and many other categories.
A "dynamical system" is mostly just a shared abstraction that's useful for theorizing on the behaviour of systems and their behaviour over time -- especially a common set of phenomena like chaos, etc.
System is too general and underspecified and dynamic system is unclearly specified because you done know whether it readily exposes the interfaces/frameworks that someone would use to theorize about dynamical systems.
So dynamic means nothing but the 'al' means interface+framework+theorize ?
The addition of the Latin-originating -al suffix to the Greek word dynamic was deliberately chosen in 1927 when dynamical systems where first widely accepted by mathematicians to be a useful way of framing things in order to specifically separate it from the dozen things in physics that already used the name dynamics, since the mathematicians looking to axiomatise the things we now call dynamical systems wanted to get physicists to stay away from it and let the math community keep it for themselves.
Back at that point in history there was a much fiercer rivalry between the two fields.
I am just here to say that I love the visuals...
I was going to say "of course chemistry can be simplified into geometry, since chemistry literally becomes real world geometry in the real world", but I've realised that that misses nuance. Even early into the article, in "Chemical systems have surprising behaviours" it becomes pretty clear how such a sentence misses nuance (I'm not entirely sure oscilation between PH and other properties has an obvious real-world-geometry analogue, for example). So yeah pretty interesting article, thumbs up emoji
Oscillations are deeply geometric in dynamical systems. Geometry has a lot of meaning, most pretty far reaching, especially in math and physics
Oscillations are quite common when you allow energy to be exchanged between forms.
Potential and kinetic energy oscillating back and forth are responsible for: planetary orbits, electromagnetic radiation, water waves, sound.
Not sure how commonplace this is, but I like thinking about it in signal-processing terms:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In-phase_and_quadrature_compon...
I mean there's a lot of diffeq stuff when you get into kinetics, and that's very NOT geometry
Well there's the whole field of differential geometry...
rust demo: https://github.com/mxfactorial/geonum/blob/main/tests/chemis...
https://xkcd.com/435/
I was gonna say 739, myself https://xkcd.com/793/
Well, considering that geometry is actually algebra...
jk
If only they'd taught chemistry like this in high school.
Suddenly, the web pages became 10x longer with 10x more images, images turned into interactive animations etc. Usually the goal for the content of a page, that has a "Conclusions" section at the end, is to provide enough evidence to support the conclusions. The size of such supportive evidence usually depends on the cognitive abilities and contextual presence of the audience and effort required for producing the content.
Conclusion: Based on the above, the 10x increase in the page content is hereby concluded to be due to the drastically reduced effort in producing the content.
"we would be forced to study complex chemical systems on a case-by-case basis, and each new case would be fraught with terrible analytical difficulties" - oddly we are entering an age to brute force this
You should have seen what it was like when the most forceful tool almost anyone had was a slide rule . . .
That was pretty brutal but plenty of people were still not discouraged.
It is architecture.
cant understand whats the anology ...
Crystals interacting with a fluid environment is weird and probablistic.
Consider rock candy growing in solution.
If only reality was cube based, like some kind of Egany Minecraft thing.
Mandatory Xkcd on the subject: https://xkcd.com/435/
This appears to be true quantum chemistry and quantum circuit simulation as well; Complex Grassmanian GrC geometry and Layer-Coded Plabic VRC-SPA Ansatz to solve the speed-accuracy barrier:
- "Layer-Coded Plabic Graphs, Complex Vector-Relation Configurations (VRC), and Unrestricted Grassmannian Quantum Chemistry (QCI-GXC) in MADNESS Multiwavelet MRA-PNO and Tequila for Computational Advantage" (2026) > "2.1 Master Taxonomy Table of Lower Grassmannians in Quantum Chemistry, MADNESS MRA-PNO, and Tequila" https://westurner.github.io/sustainablefactory/grassmannian-... , https://westurner.github.io/sustainablefactory/grassmannian-...