Admittedly I have zero experience job hunting in the US startup scene. But if a company I was interviewing for asked for the password to one of my personal accounts I would refuse. Would I do free work for them as well? Probably not.
I find it hard to believe this stuff is a thing...
Hard to believe people desperate for a job get taken advantage of? That doesn’t seem hard to believe. I’ve heard from many people about trying to get jobs at companies just to find they are essentially using the interview process and “tests” as free labor. Each person who figures out moves on or gets mad, and that company just moves on to the next “applicants”.
The companies feel justified as though the interview process should be beneficial to them and not cost them time/money. To companies like them, applicants are free unpaid interns.
It would be fabulous if there was a public database to shame these companies for such practices. Though this is free market economics at work, it's shameful, and could be squelched if we had the data
It just feels so counterproductive in 90% of skilled jobs, what skilled job can you be productive within a day? This specific case seems more about hijacking the person's linkedin profile than the actual labor.
Design a marketing campaign for X product; product Y is failing certification lab tests, how would you fix it; department Z is constantly under budget and ahead of time despite already doing this and that, how would you fix it; product Q is hard and expensive to manufacture, how would you streamline design; what is the main competitive advantage of the ${main-competitor} against us and how would you close the gap; if ${minor-competitor} were to announce market[-segment] exit next year, how would you fill the market-vacuum against ${main-competitor}?
Companies/departments outside of hyper-growth stage do not necessarily hire because they lack sheer manpower capacity.
They didn't ask for the password as far as I understood, but asked the applicant to connect their linkedIn account to some platform so they can use that during the interview.
Not okay from the company to keep using this after the interview, but also risky from the interviewed not to revoke that access after the interview.
"Connecting" one's LinkedIn seems the foremost way this company intends to work with their own clients: https://standout.work/#how-it-works . But why would anyone enable a company as part of this process to have anything more than read-only access, and in particular: why would one grant anyone the right to post in one's own name?!
Edit: Embarrassingly, this sounds as if I intended to criticize the applicant, which was certainly not my intention. Personally, I often only glance superficially at lists of requested permissions. It is astonishing that this company has the chutzpah to demand posting rights.
Maybe there is no job and that’s just their growth hacking strategy. I’m assuming that without even reading the article since I can’t think of any credible reason they need a candidate’s account credentials for any service
They're not just abusing the candidate's credentials, they're burning their reputation by posting AI generated spam to other people under their names. Insideious reputational sabotage!
Agreed and I'm enduring the US. Firm no. Not even linking/revoking, ridiculous charade.
It's easier to believe once you see the selection filters across our society and their unfortunate effectiveness, this one aims for applicants without many options or the willpower to seek them.
The intention is to remove folks like us. If this test is refused, 'difficulty' would be the answer for moving on. The actual reason is not being primed for exploitation. Difficulty to take advantage of, for sure, but not the failing of interpersonal skills they'll probably represent.
I was once asked by a new colleague, "were you abused?"; I didn't have the heart to say the truth: we both were and will be.
> I find it hard to believe this stuff is a thing...
This sort of abuse runs rampant. There are companies who even require periods of unpaid internship as a precondition to be considered for a role, which is of course also severely underpaid and subjected to abuse.
Not trying to justify bad practices, but with AI cheating on interviews being rampart it's obvious companies will find all other possible ways to hire. And this will get abused a lot.
“30+ hours” of free labour in the recruitment process is something YC should put their foot down about, by itself.
If that was happening in the UK (or Europe AFAIK) it would be a straightforward breach of employment law.
In the UK it’s certainly legal to ask a potential candidate to work an unpaid trial shift as part of the recruitment process (it can be an effective way for some candidates to show they are capable when they don’t do so well in formal interviews) but the rule is simple: the potential employer is not supposed to gain directly from this process. So if someone is supervised or monitored during the shift, for example, the gain from their work is offset by the loss of direct usefulness of the employee supervising.
A single “shift” should not even be a full day; that is unlikely to meet the associated reasonableness test. At 12 hours of work from the candidate that would pretty certainly be breaching the law.
If a pub asks someone to “work a couple of trial shifts” even that is possibly illegal if they are not paid.
Consequently this process is not all that common outside of customer-facing work (retail and hospitality); paid probationary periods are more common.
(Given the law here about the employer not deriving a direct gain from the recruitment process itself, it seems implausible that grotesque LinkedIn shit could be legal)
ETA: I guess my main point in this under-caffeinated ramble is that YC should be making it clear that, even in a startup context, obviously uncompensated work during the recruitment process is abusive.
I know someone in the uk who was sent to work a full day as a cleaner as a trial shift where there was clearly no intention to hire her. And she had no choice but to do it or lose unemployment benefit for turning down an “interview”. When I looked it up I was surprised to see this was pretty much legal and there wasn’t anywhere to report it to.
There are some approved work-benefit schemes through “jobcentre plus”, but it cannot be open recruitment. Those can actually last a lot longer. But they are by definition not an “interview” in the open recruitment sense because they can only be offered to a single person, and they are voluntary by definition. Also they can mandate some unpaid workplace training in long term benefit claim situations. But she is supposed to receive training in the process.
If what happened to her happens again in the context of an ordinary interview, she should talk to Citizens Advice about it, and (potentially at least) contact the DWP outside of her normal job centre process. Because the law does have requirements here, and a full day, if the supervisor worked alongside her without offering training, or left her alone, is probably illegal. (A four hour shift left alone would be, even)
(If it’s happening routinely and you have the means to help her get an appointment with an employment lawyer for advice, that could be a way to help her, because the benefit process is not without its legal failings and there are some companies abusing it)
All correct until the ampersand. I pay less tax % in London than I would in CA or NY. My son was birthed by C-section for nothing and gets 30 hours of free childcare a week. Beat that with a stick.
They should understand that this sort of hiring process would be a criminal breach of employment law in the UK (and the LinkedIn sleaziness probably breaks some other laws)
It’s weird to visit reddit because I rarely go on now after their login changes—anyway here’s what I perceive to be the crux from the “article”:
> During the trial, I connected my personal LinkedIn to their platform. It was a pre-requisite.
Other comments make it seem like Author wrote their credentials on a paper or something but it’s not clear from what I understand. It seems like linking the account or something via API, but I don’t know specifics either.
Yes, linking is different. I once used an AI recruiting website which I will not mention to not drive traffic to their shitty business. After a 20min AI-call (yes, with voice) they told me that I had to connect my linked in profile. The issue is: I don't have a LinkedIn profile. The AI went in circle but couldn't handle the information. In the end I never worked with them again.
To be fair, I am a bit tired of those calls - they are literally all the same and can be handled by AI. I have been on the other side of the table hiring people, and you are just overwhelmed by profiles and candidates, a large part of them being low-quality fakeit-till-you-makeit (read: their CV reads as a rockstar dev, but fail at most basic programming tasks). This basically filters out the shotgun applicants that apply to 100s of jobs. If you don't invest 20minutes of your time, you probably already know you are not a good fit for that job.
Should the same apply to the recruiters? Maybe, but right now we are in a sellers market (way more applicants than jobs).
> This basically filters out the shotgun applicants that apply to 100s of jobs.
So request aplications by snail mail.
We did this, and magicly, we now only get genuine candidates with a real interest in the roles. No fancy AI shite needed. Just a real human connection.
The point of any technology is to make life easier and better. If it dosn't do that, then don't use it.
Your wording almost makes it sound like you're saying their incompetence is at being caught, not that they're just absurdly incompetent and stupid for doing such a thing at all.
Should also be reported to LinkedIn's abuse address, if they have one. That might help others in the same situation, if LI can be arsed to block the company's access
If LinkedIn was sane, they would not even give such option in their API.
I hope no one forgot LinkedIn literally did the same, in their beginning. On signup they asked you for access to contact list to "search for colleagues", and spammed everyone without account with personal invitation to LinkedIn, with you as sender.
> After 3 weeks of silence, I discovered they have been using my LinkedIn to send connection requests and messages from my account without my knowledge.
Tangental, but various government departments often ask for passwords. I understand it's common for immigration - e.g. 'border patrol' might flag someone mildly suspicious when entering a country, interrogate them, and encourage them to proactively demonstrate their innocence.
I think it's madness to give passwords to social media or devices, partly because many people reuse passwords so giving 1 password is the same as giving many.
Incidentally, under a law passed in September 2026, NSW Police can seize your phone and read everything on it during a routine road stop if their request is approved by a judge via email or phone. You can be required by law to unlock your phone (refusal is itself a criminal offence), and if you refuse, access can be gained and its entire contents copied via tools like Cellebrite. Big Brother!
> It is a startup, of course their main goal is money.
How a startup goes about making money is not a fundamental law of the universe. It's a choice the founders make, pushed from behind by the VCs who finance them. The VCs say "grow at any cost", then when the cost is too embarrassing maybe they drop a blog post redefining "any". Or maybe they do nothing because it all blows over soon, people forget, and go back to praising those same VCs for their wealth of wisdom.
It's one of those things. I once gave my account password together with my MacBook at an Apple store (it went back for a GPU swap).
I felt so bad that I did it, there went my whole personal life, so many people I don't know who could then touch it. I vouched never to do it again. But there is this "officialness" that persuades you in the moment.
Here it may have felt like that, but there is also a toxic power-imbalance if they ask your LI account password and you feel like you have to comply. Huge red flag. Let us all learn from this. A line must be drawn and you need to learn where by going over it sometimes (you should never give people power over your identity; "Why do you need to be me?" you could ask).
> I once gave my account password together with my MacBook at an Apple store (it went back for a GPU swap).
I wiped my SSD when I sent my MacBook in.
The Apple staff told me that I could have created another admin account with the password "apple" for them instead, except when I tested that option, it could access my files anyway.
It wouldn't be able to access your account-related information (passwords in keychain, apple ID, etc.)
Still pretty bad, though. Too much valuable information in "regular" files. If possible, I always wipe devices before bringing them in for service. (Good reminder to have some kind of regular backup plan.)
And I still don't understand why they need it. Just boot from a USB drive if you need to verify if everything works. (Or even drop another internal drive in while it's opened up.)
Regular admins cannot compromise the secure enclave. I'm pretty sure to unlock the keychain the first time, you need to authenticate through the secure enclave.
(Of course, Apple could roll out a rogue macOS/sepOS, but they could do that at any time.)
Well, this was pre-secure enclave, an MBP 15" from 2011? Would have still used it today probably if they wouldn't have replaced that GPU with a new and again defective GPU. I had just replaced the hdd with an ssd, added 8 GB of RAM and bought a new battery when it failed the second time. Never bought another MacBook after that. (Actually after failing I desoldered the GPU via 1 connection and it ran perfectly fine for a couple of days on the iGPU... But a software update bricked it!)
But you know, my Daughter still takes my OG Moto G with her when needed (from 2013, just got a message on it that next year they'll turn of 2G and it can't be on a network anymore). So perhaps I'm not your typical tech user ;)
Any machine old enough to need a GPU replacement wouldn't have had a secure enclave.
That being said - each user's keychain is encrypted using their account password. You can't read another user's keychain without knowing their password.
I did this every single time and every single time they would be really weirdly upset about it. The manager of the store later got fired and caught charges for taking nudes from peoples macbooks
> I once gave my account password together with my MacBook at an Apple store
Is this still the case? I used to wipe all devices before repair at the Apple Store, but that has become too inconvenient and impractical. I'd rather suffer with a broken device if I can't repair it myself.
My Macbook had a swollend battery (older model ~2011). I brought it to the service center to replace. They asked for the password, I said no. No problem. I guess they could not run some tests of whatever, it still worked at the end.
because YC became a badge - i.e the end result in itself not part of the journey - you now have plenty of founders who are cowards and frauds seeking the YC badge
I've seen a couple of blog posts mentioning and recruiting websites, that linking your LinkedIn profile is required for the application. Am I the only one who is not having a linked in profile? I mean given the shitshow it has converted, I wonder why people even are on there.
I recall when LinkedIn, as a startup, spammed your contacts with emails from "you" asking your friends to join.
Quite how anybody ever trusted them after this is simply beyond me, they were utterly toxic. Back then, anybody with a LinkedIn account would be automaticly rejected; either because they had zero security sense, or because they were out of touch with tech news.
So no, I've never had a LinkedIn account, and never will.
Seems their whole premise is LinkedIn vouching, but why would a company force you to connect your LinkedIn. After Delve and other shady things YC companies do, why would I ever choose them over the many open-source alternatives popping up?
Waiting for their CEO to post an explanation here. Let's help Algolia reference this company, shall we?
Hello Standout (YC P26) CEO, can you please explain what happened here? It does not look good. Not only does the unpaid work trial seem excessive, but then, reusing an unauthorized LinkedIn account 3 weeks later? That's unexpected.
"Standout® is now SmartReach®! This user-focused rebrand will enable us to deliver a clearer, more transparent vision of our customer-obsessed culture. We are excited about our new journey and invite you to be part of it!"
(Note that a company called "SmartReach" already exists - I thought about changing the made-up name but good luck finding two generic words that haven't already been taken by marketing companies)
My weak counter-argument would be that "euthanasia" is not generic.
My stronger argument would be that "euthanasia disco" is a term Jack Ladder coined to describe his song Susan, which I'll use to argue that it has, indeed, become a marketing term.
(I only learned about the song right now. It's worth a listen.)
This is Alexis Aftalion's actual video promoting his company Standup -- I will let it speak for itself, and preserve the transcript here lest he take it down. That Y Combinator fell for this bullshit hook line and sinker says more than I could possibly write:
448 views May 6, 2026
Standout (YC S26) is an AI career agent connecting top operators with the best startups. We deliver introductions, not applications. A real agent on every match, supercharged by AI to move 10x faster than a recruiter at a fraction of the cost.
Every year, startups lose billions hiring the wrong people, and the best operators miss the roles that would have defined their careers. Recruiter spam, ghosted applications, mismatched intros, missed windows. The roles that define a decade go to people inside small networks most candidates can't reach. We have that network. Our AI handles the rest.
Transcript:
TIME LEFT TO ESCAPE THE PERMANENT UNDERCLASS: 01 YEAR 07 MONTH 13 DAYS
Message from Claudia Crush: hey can't do dinner tonight
Message from Claudia Crush: going out with my ex, he just signd at ElevenLabs for 800k [emoji heart hands]
Message from Cosimo: Big news - I have officially joined @ElevenLabs [likely ai generated photo of smiling man holding WELCOME TO 11ElevenLabs cake, presumably the ex of Alex's love interest who just broke up with him because her ex got a better job than Alex's, which is the motivation for the rest of the video]
Alex: founding engineer
I need to call my agent.
Message from Alex to Standout: I need to make a move
Message from Standout to Alex: let's chat
Alexis Aftalion, CEO at Standout, in person:
You are finally deciding to take your talent elsewhere.
Alex:
Yeah, I feel like there's this window of opportunity right now. I don't even know what to look for and I just I want to be in the best position to maximize my potential.
Popup: Establishing Context. Checking Linkedin... SF-based ex-Vercel -> founding engineer at YC S24 startup. Strong systems. AGI House 2nd place.
Alexis:
Yeah, look, you've got some talent, that's for sure. But here is the problem. You just see 5% of what's out there. What you need is someone plugged in that know your value and the market, and gets your foot in the door. But here is the real question. What do you want?
Popup: Mapping opportunities... [off-the-shelf D3 animation of icons and links in an expanding graph] Curating opportunities... Working on intros...
Alex: I want an AI native company [music] that's small but with a cracked team.
Alexis:
And what are we building?
Alex:
Infrastructure for robotics. [music] I want to have a hand in designing the future.
Alexis:
Let's talk numbers.
Alex:
Minimum 0.5%. Post funding. Salary north of [$$$ kaching bell sound censoring actual figure]. Unlimited AI tokens and the ability to build a team around me.
Alexis:
Give me 24 hours.
[music] [phone rings, call from Standout]
Alexis:
I've got three tailored opportunities for you. All of them want final round.
Alex:
Great. Well... Show me the money.
Fake NGMI news show screen with text overlays: NGMI THEME SONG GENERATED BY 11ElevenLabs / "Alexis Aftalion @alexisaftalion | Witold DLC @saas7w / ALEX: "THE DECISION" / NGMI NGMI NGMI NGMI NGMI ...
Announcer:
We are live from NGMI. Alex, what is your decision?
Alex:
The one on the right, [music]
Alexis:
18 months from IPO.
Announcer:
You're surrounded by journals. Hold your position.
Text message from Standout: first day tomorrow
Text message from Standout: go be excellent
Overlay text: Standout. Top talent doesn't apply, top talent gets represented.
It didn't exist until you searched for it. Somehow some scam company bought access to Google's autocomplete traffic and figured out that at 16,000 tokens per second they can just squeak by and fill every single search result with slop and then finish generating the (completely nonfunctional) slop sites in the few seconds that the user is looking at "search" results. If you click on the company you think already existed, you'll see that it's completely made-up, it was just made up when you searched for it. Everything's like that now.
Google may be experimenting with replacing all of your received email in GMail with slop fabricated by the highest bidder as well.
At this rate, they don't even need to hire anyone. These geniuses, morality be damned, have figured out how to have free labor and profit from job applicants!
Nobody working a few days or even a week is doing anything of value, simply because they cant opossibly understand the big picture if they are working on any large system. THe reality is they are probably contributing something that is broken or will become technical debt very quickly.
So it was standout: https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/standout, what a shock that combining recruiting & AI leads to some shady tactics. I've been spammed by "agentic recruiters" to my github & linkedin accounts.
Jokes on them because I’ve already learned that almost every recruiter who reaches out on LinkedIn is just indiscriminate automated spam in one form or another. What next, a YC startup promising to get your band a record deal via MySpace?
As a tangent, can any lawyer clarify, is it illegal for a job applicant if you push everything you are asked to do as part of job applications through AI agents and rip off the most valuable parts of the product to make a clone or to sell competitive intelligence. Anyways seems like a cool idea I can pitch to angel investors :)
But this is what most people would call "growth hacking" or whatever, which is "good" and I wouldn't be surprised if these people raised more millions for their gumption.
i didnt look too hard at their site but isnt the whole idea that an agent looks for work for you while you do other things and the agent sends messages on your behalf?
Someone from YC should promptly and officially post to this discussion that Standout has been kicked out of Y Combinator, and why, as a warning to all other Y Combinator companies and applicants.
And Y Combinator should fully cooperate with all police investigations and lawsuits against Standout, to show they actually don't support Standout's fraudulent crimes and ethical attrocities. Otherwise it looks like Y Combinator actually condones, encourages, and finances this kind of criminal bullshit.
If you read all the comments in the reddit and hn discussions, it's obvious that Y Combinator itself is suffering reputational harm from Standout's actions, so they have a good reason to sue Standout themselves. At the very least they should demand that Standout return all their money, after reimbursing all their victims for their wasted time and damaged reputations.
Couldnt care less about the rejection but how is using a candidate’s personal LinkedIn to conduct business without their permission acceptable?
It may not be. Half of the ycomb startups are run by grifters. A number of them wind up on the fastcompany cover, then jail within 2 years. Fastcompany curse.
You have no concept have many felons and con men run in that crowd. No offense intended to felons for associating them with the hive of scum and villainy that is silicon valley.
BeekeeperZero
14h ago
Grifters is too nice of a description for the majority of ycomb. Narcissistic, entitled, psychopaths would be a bit more spot on.
VisitPier26
13h ago
exactly. people think everyone of these founders is Elizabeth Holmes. The reality is that they may not all be fraudsters, but they are definitely narcissistic hacks.
Change your password, don't give out your credentials again, and be content that you've learned an important lesson that will make you a better hire for whoever eventually gives you a chance.
They didn't share their password, they "connected [their] LinkedIn". They likely had to accept whatever permission grant the company's app was asking for (which likely included something along the lines of "act on your behalf") but these tend to be extremely coarse to the point that users are used to having to grant broad permissions for trivial legitimate reasons - e.g. every other browser extension asks for permission to "access all websites".
That doesn't seem like a mistake, seems to me like malice.
I remember someone tried to pull this on me, sent a take home assignment that was clearly just a feature they wanted in their software. I called them out on it but said I'd be happy to do it and bill for it. We had a call to chat about it and they outright admitted they were using the take home assignment as free labor.
Apparently they actually did hire someone in the end but, jesus.
That is nowhere near enough. They damaged their all of their applicants' reputations by spamming many other people with ai slop under the applicants' names.
They owe each an every applicant hard cold cash compensation that they can pay their mortgage and buy food with, not a getaway vacation at a time in their lives when the economy is so totally fucked by Trump's war in Iran, unaffordabl gas and food prices, and financial fallout from tarrifs, while they're out of work, busy looking for a job in a market devistated by ai, and don't have time for a getaway vacation.
And they owe every single other person they spammed under their victims' names a personal apology from THEIR OWN LinkedIn account, taking responsibility and blame for the spam, and explaining that their applicant victims were deceived and did not send that spam. Nothing less is fair to all the victims involved.
And by no means should they move on. They should Standdown not Standout: shut down the company, move back to France with their own reputation in shambles, and never try anything like that ever again. Pick another company? Sheeeeeit, they'd better pick another industry instead. There is no moving on from what they did.
Admittedly I have zero experience job hunting in the US startup scene. But if a company I was interviewing for asked for the password to one of my personal accounts I would refuse. Would I do free work for them as well? Probably not.
I find it hard to believe this stuff is a thing...
> hard to believe
Hard to believe people desperate for a job get taken advantage of? That doesn’t seem hard to believe. I’ve heard from many people about trying to get jobs at companies just to find they are essentially using the interview process and “tests” as free labor. Each person who figures out moves on or gets mad, and that company just moves on to the next “applicants”.
The companies feel justified as though the interview process should be beneficial to them and not cost them time/money. To companies like them, applicants are free unpaid interns.
It would be fabulous if there was a public database to shame these companies for such practices. Though this is free market economics at work, it's shameful, and could be squelched if we had the data
It just feels so counterproductive in 90% of skilled jobs, what skilled job can you be productive within a day? This specific case seems more about hijacking the person's linkedin profile than the actual labor.
Outside perspective can be very valuable.
Design a marketing campaign for X product; product Y is failing certification lab tests, how would you fix it; department Z is constantly under budget and ahead of time despite already doing this and that, how would you fix it; product Q is hard and expensive to manufacture, how would you streamline design; what is the main competitive advantage of the ${main-competitor} against us and how would you close the gap; if ${minor-competitor} were to announce market[-segment] exit next year, how would you fill the market-vacuum against ${main-competitor}?
Companies/departments outside of hyper-growth stage do not necessarily hire because they lack sheer manpower capacity.
They didn't ask for the password as far as I understood, but asked the applicant to connect their linkedIn account to some platform so they can use that during the interview. Not okay from the company to keep using this after the interview, but also risky from the interviewed not to revoke that access after the interview.
"Connecting" one's LinkedIn seems the foremost way this company intends to work with their own clients: https://standout.work/#how-it-works . But why would anyone enable a company as part of this process to have anything more than read-only access, and in particular: why would one grant anyone the right to post in one's own name?!
Edit: Embarrassingly, this sounds as if I intended to criticize the applicant, which was certainly not my intention. Personally, I often only glance superficially at lists of requested permissions. It is astonishing that this company has the chutzpah to demand posting rights.
...to be able to put food on the table? Yes, it's abuse, and let's not blame the victim.
Job market in IT is awful right now, not just in US, but globally.
If letting company exploit my LinkedIn with 20,000+ connections would landed me on a job I would't disagreed.
After all LinkedIn is useless for finding a job now. At least someone will profit off it.
Maybe there is no job and that’s just their growth hacking strategy. I’m assuming that without even reading the article since I can’t think of any credible reason they need a candidate’s account credentials for any service
They're not just abusing the candidate's credentials, they're burning their reputation by posting AI generated spam to other people under their names. Insideious reputational sabotage!
Agreed and I'm enduring the US. Firm no. Not even linking/revoking, ridiculous charade.
It's easier to believe once you see the selection filters across our society and their unfortunate effectiveness, this one aims for applicants without many options or the willpower to seek them.
The intention is to remove folks like us. If this test is refused, 'difficulty' would be the answer for moving on. The actual reason is not being primed for exploitation. Difficulty to take advantage of, for sure, but not the failing of interpersonal skills they'll probably represent.
I was once asked by a new colleague, "were you abused?"; I didn't have the heart to say the truth: we both were and will be.
> I find it hard to believe this stuff is a thing...
This sort of abuse runs rampant. There are companies who even require periods of unpaid internship as a precondition to be considered for a role, which is of course also severely underpaid and subjected to abuse.
Not trying to justify bad practices, but with AI cheating on interviews being rampart it's obvious companies will find all other possible ways to hire. And this will get abused a lot.
If a company I was working for asked I'd refuse, much less interviewing. You don't own my identity just cause you pay my salary.
“30+ hours” of free labour in the recruitment process is something YC should put their foot down about, by itself.
If that was happening in the UK (or Europe AFAIK) it would be a straightforward breach of employment law.
In the UK it’s certainly legal to ask a potential candidate to work an unpaid trial shift as part of the recruitment process (it can be an effective way for some candidates to show they are capable when they don’t do so well in formal interviews) but the rule is simple: the potential employer is not supposed to gain directly from this process. So if someone is supervised or monitored during the shift, for example, the gain from their work is offset by the loss of direct usefulness of the employee supervising.
A single “shift” should not even be a full day; that is unlikely to meet the associated reasonableness test. At 12 hours of work from the candidate that would pretty certainly be breaching the law.
If a pub asks someone to “work a couple of trial shifts” even that is possibly illegal if they are not paid.
Consequently this process is not all that common outside of customer-facing work (retail and hospitality); paid probationary periods are more common.
(Given the law here about the employer not deriving a direct gain from the recruitment process itself, it seems implausible that grotesque LinkedIn shit could be legal)
ETA: I guess my main point in this under-caffeinated ramble is that YC should be making it clear that, even in a startup context, obviously uncompensated work during the recruitment process is abusive.
I know someone in the uk who was sent to work a full day as a cleaner as a trial shift where there was clearly no intention to hire her. And she had no choice but to do it or lose unemployment benefit for turning down an “interview”. When I looked it up I was surprised to see this was pretty much legal and there wasn’t anywhere to report it to.
There are some approved work-benefit schemes through “jobcentre plus”, but it cannot be open recruitment. Those can actually last a lot longer. But they are by definition not an “interview” in the open recruitment sense because they can only be offered to a single person, and they are voluntary by definition. Also they can mandate some unpaid workplace training in long term benefit claim situations. But she is supposed to receive training in the process.
If what happened to her happens again in the context of an ordinary interview, she should talk to Citizens Advice about it, and (potentially at least) contact the DWP outside of her normal job centre process. Because the law does have requirements here, and a full day, if the supervisor worked alongside her without offering training, or left her alone, is probably illegal. (A four hour shift left alone would be, even)
(If it’s happening routinely and you have the means to help her get an appointment with an employment lawyer for advice, that could be a way to help her, because the benefit process is not without its legal failings and there are some companies abusing it)
YC advises their companies to hire in the UK - talent is just as good for half the cost & they pay double the tax.
All correct until the ampersand. I pay less tax % in London than I would in CA or NY. My son was birthed by C-section for nothing and gets 30 hours of free childcare a week. Beat that with a stick.
They should understand that this sort of hiring process would be a criminal breach of employment law in the UK (and the LinkedIn sleaziness probably breaks some other laws)
Double the tax is complete nonsense, as the sibling points out. You can easily verify this with online tax calculators for CA and the UK.
It’s weird to visit reddit because I rarely go on now after their login changes—anyway here’s what I perceive to be the crux from the “article”:
> During the trial, I connected my personal LinkedIn to their platform. It was a pre-requisite.
Other comments make it seem like Author wrote their credentials on a paper or something but it’s not clear from what I understand. It seems like linking the account or something via API, but I don’t know specifics either.
Yes, linking is different. I once used an AI recruiting website which I will not mention to not drive traffic to their shitty business. After a 20min AI-call (yes, with voice) they told me that I had to connect my linked in profile. The issue is: I don't have a LinkedIn profile. The AI went in circle but couldn't handle the information. In the end I never worked with them again.
> After a 20min AI-call
Sorry mate, you lost me there.
If they can't be arsed speaking to you, why should you be arsed speaking to them?
To be fair, I am a bit tired of those calls - they are literally all the same and can be handled by AI. I have been on the other side of the table hiring people, and you are just overwhelmed by profiles and candidates, a large part of them being low-quality fakeit-till-you-makeit (read: their CV reads as a rockstar dev, but fail at most basic programming tasks). This basically filters out the shotgun applicants that apply to 100s of jobs. If you don't invest 20minutes of your time, you probably already know you are not a good fit for that job.
Should the same apply to the recruiters? Maybe, but right now we are in a sellers market (way more applicants than jobs).
> This basically filters out the shotgun applicants that apply to 100s of jobs.
So request aplications by snail mail.
We did this, and magicly, we now only get genuine candidates with a real interest in the roles. No fancy AI shite needed. Just a real human connection.
The point of any technology is to make life easier and better. If it dosn't do that, then don't use it.
They should absolutely be sued for this type of incompetence. What an absurdly stupid thing for them to get caught doing.
Your wording almost makes it sound like you're saying their incompetence is at being caught, not that they're just absurdly incompetent and stupid for doing such a thing at all.
Should also be reported to LinkedIn's abuse address, if they have one. That might help others in the same situation, if LI can be arsed to block the company's access
If LinkedIn was sane, they would not even give such option in their API. I hope no one forgot LinkedIn literally did the same, in their beginning. On signup they asked you for access to contact list to "search for colleagues", and spammed everyone without account with personal invitation to LinkedIn, with you as sender.
The guy should've received at least $3000, right? Surely one of those leads went somewhere.
https://standout.work/refer
> After 3 weeks of silence, I discovered they have been using my LinkedIn to send connection requests and messages from my account without my knowledge.
Wow shame on the YC company standout
Tangental, but various government departments often ask for passwords. I understand it's common for immigration - e.g. 'border patrol' might flag someone mildly suspicious when entering a country, interrogate them, and encourage them to proactively demonstrate their innocence.
I think it's madness to give passwords to social media or devices, partly because many people reuse passwords so giving 1 password is the same as giving many.
Incidentally, under a law passed in September 2026, NSW Police can seize your phone and read everything on it during a routine road stop if their request is approved by a judge via email or phone. You can be required by law to unlock your phone (refusal is itself a criminal offence), and if you refuse, access can be gained and its entire contents copied via tools like Cellebrite. Big Brother!
Source: https://www.sydneycriminallawyers.com.au/blog/nsw-police-giv...
This has been flagged and is now on page #3 which means it is effectively dead.
The title of this post should be edited to include the company name for clarity - Standout (YC P26).
seems so commonplace at YC now im not even surprised
There is something to say about YC growth-at-all-costs culture.
From Graham’s essays: "A good growth rate during YC is 5-7% a week."[1] This number gets thrown out a lot.
Partners might look for unethical “focused” founders. Founders themselves might throw ethics and common sense.
Anything to match the growth rate.
[1] https://www.paulgraham.com/growth.html
It is no wonder startup has already become a curse word. It is a startup, of course their main goal is money.
> It is a startup, of course their main goal is money.
How a startup goes about making money is not a fundamental law of the universe. It's a choice the founders make, pushed from behind by the VCs who finance them. The VCs say "grow at any cost", then when the cost is too embarrassing maybe they drop a blog post redefining "any". Or maybe they do nothing because it all blows over soon, people forget, and go back to praising those same VCs for their wealth of wisdom.
Growth isn't even about money, it's about metrics. If you're a startup, profit comes later.
"Built for when you’re not looking." << from the startup's website
That is basically illegal. You should sue.
It's one of those things. I once gave my account password together with my MacBook at an Apple store (it went back for a GPU swap).
I felt so bad that I did it, there went my whole personal life, so many people I don't know who could then touch it. I vouched never to do it again. But there is this "officialness" that persuades you in the moment.
Here it may have felt like that, but there is also a toxic power-imbalance if they ask your LI account password and you feel like you have to comply. Huge red flag. Let us all learn from this. A line must be drawn and you need to learn where by going over it sometimes (you should never give people power over your identity; "Why do you need to be me?" you could ask).
> I once gave my account password together with my MacBook at an Apple store (it went back for a GPU swap).
I wiped my SSD when I sent my MacBook in.
The Apple staff told me that I could have created another admin account with the password "apple" for them instead, except when I tested that option, it could access my files anyway.
It wouldn't be able to access your account-related information (passwords in keychain, apple ID, etc.)
Still pretty bad, though. Too much valuable information in "regular" files. If possible, I always wipe devices before bringing them in for service. (Good reminder to have some kind of regular backup plan.)
And I still don't understand why they need it. Just boot from a USB drive if you need to verify if everything works. (Or even drop another internal drive in while it's opened up.)
Sure they can, admins can just grant themselves access to other folders
Regular admins cannot compromise the secure enclave. I'm pretty sure to unlock the keychain the first time, you need to authenticate through the secure enclave.
(Of course, Apple could roll out a rogue macOS/sepOS, but they could do that at any time.)
Well, this was pre-secure enclave, an MBP 15" from 2011? Would have still used it today probably if they wouldn't have replaced that GPU with a new and again defective GPU. I had just replaced the hdd with an ssd, added 8 GB of RAM and bought a new battery when it failed the second time. Never bought another MacBook after that. (Actually after failing I desoldered the GPU via 1 connection and it ran perfectly fine for a couple of days on the iGPU... But a software update bricked it!)
But you know, my Daughter still takes my OG Moto G with her when needed (from 2013, just got a message on it that next year they'll turn of 2G and it can't be on a network anymore). So perhaps I'm not your typical tech user ;)
Any machine old enough to need a GPU replacement wouldn't have had a secure enclave.
That being said - each user's keychain is encrypted using their account password. You can't read another user's keychain without knowing their password.
I did this every single time and every single time they would be really weirdly upset about it. The manager of the store later got fired and caught charges for taking nudes from peoples macbooks
My local certified Apple reseller used to do the same thing. It just feels so wrong. At the time I wrote to Apple support to complain about this.
> I once gave my account password together with my MacBook at an Apple store
Is this still the case? I used to wipe all devices before repair at the Apple Store, but that has become too inconvenient and impractical. I'd rather suffer with a broken device if I can't repair it myself.
My Macbook had a swollend battery (older model ~2011). I brought it to the service center to replace. They asked for the password, I said no. No problem. I guess they could not run some tests of whatever, it still worked at the end.
because YC became a badge - i.e the end result in itself not part of the journey - you now have plenty of founders who are cowards and frauds seeking the YC badge
tell me a time you hacked a (non)computer system to your advantage
I've seen a couple of blog posts mentioning and recruiting websites, that linking your LinkedIn profile is required for the application. Am I the only one who is not having a linked in profile? I mean given the shitshow it has converted, I wonder why people even are on there.
> I wonder why people even are on there.
I recall when LinkedIn, as a startup, spammed your contacts with emails from "you" asking your friends to join.
Quite how anybody ever trusted them after this is simply beyond me, they were utterly toxic. Back then, anybody with a LinkedIn account would be automaticly rejected; either because they had zero security sense, or because they were out of touch with tech news.
So no, I've never had a LinkedIn account, and never will.
Please sue them. They shouldn't get away with this.
Time for some YC partners to show some leadership.
You mean like with InstallMonetizer? Naive? LendUp? Homejoy? Central? StableGains? Delve? Wakemate? UBiome? and many others...
You all need a GDPR.
Doesn't California have very specific data privacy laws?
Also the US infamously has some pretty harsh cybercrime laws and this sounds like a perfect example of the kind of shit that violates them.
The author definitely has a civil case but they might also have a criminal (felony) case against the company.
This is the company: https://standout.work
Seems their whole premise is LinkedIn vouching, but why would a company force you to connect your LinkedIn. After Delve and other shady things YC companies do, why would I ever choose them over the many open-source alternatives popping up?
Dogfooding, increasing normalization of the workflow.
Waiting for their CEO to post an explanation here. Let's help Algolia reference this company, shall we?
Hello Standout (YC P26) CEO, can you please explain what happened here? It does not look good. Not only does the unpaid work trial seem excessive, but then, reusing an unauthorized LinkedIn account 3 weeks later? That's unexpected.
I'm personally waiting for the rebrand.
"Standout® is now SmartReach®! This user-focused rebrand will enable us to deliver a clearer, more transparent vision of our customer-obsessed culture. We are excited about our new journey and invite you to be part of it!"
(Note that a company called "SmartReach" already exists - I thought about changing the made-up name but good luck finding two generic words that haven't already been taken by marketing companies)
EuthanasiaDisco
My weak counter-argument would be that "euthanasia" is not generic.
My stronger argument would be that "euthanasia disco" is a term Jack Ladder coined to describe his song Susan, which I'll use to argue that it has, indeed, become a marketing term.
(I only learned about the song right now. It's worth a listen.)
"Because your pet deserves a happy ending".
When your doggy needs a handy
Yikes
How dare you leak Israel's next ESC entry.
Standout should Standdown.
SmartReachAround optimizes the Mean Jerk-Time!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LpRh6HQrtQ
This is Alexis Aftalion's actual video promoting his company Standup -- I will let it speak for itself, and preserve the transcript here lest he take it down. That Y Combinator fell for this bullshit hook line and sinker says more than I could possibly write:
Standout — Hiring is broken. We're fixing it
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7LdjJO-ibdI
448 views May 6, 2026 Standout (YC S26) is an AI career agent connecting top operators with the best startups. We deliver introductions, not applications. A real agent on every match, supercharged by AI to move 10x faster than a recruiter at a fraction of the cost.
Every year, startups lose billions hiring the wrong people, and the best operators miss the roles that would have defined their careers. Recruiter spam, ghosted applications, mismatched intros, missed windows. The roles that define a decade go to people inside small networks most candidates can't reach. We have that network. Our AI handles the rest.
Transcript:
TIME LEFT TO ESCAPE THE PERMANENT UNDERCLASS: 01 YEAR 07 MONTH 13 DAYS
Message from Claudia Crush: hey can't do dinner tonight
Message from Claudia Crush: going out with my ex, he just signd at ElevenLabs for 800k [emoji heart hands]
Message from Cosimo: Big news - I have officially joined @ElevenLabs [likely ai generated photo of smiling man holding WELCOME TO 11ElevenLabs cake, presumably the ex of Alex's love interest who just broke up with him because her ex got a better job than Alex's, which is the motivation for the rest of the video]
Alex: founding engineer
I need to call my agent.
Message from Alex to Standout: I need to make a move
Message from Standout to Alex: let's chat
Alexis Aftalion, CEO at Standout, in person:
You are finally deciding to take your talent elsewhere.
Alex: Yeah, I feel like there's this window of opportunity right now. I don't even know what to look for and I just I want to be in the best position to maximize my potential.
Popup: Establishing Context. Checking Linkedin... SF-based ex-Vercel -> founding engineer at YC S24 startup. Strong systems. AGI House 2nd place.
Popup: Scouting Github... Ships daily green squares 47 weeks. Viral repo [...] month 400-line eval numbers. 2.8K stars week.
Popup: interpreting network... Aggregating behavior data. skill ve[...] signals. Building something new.
Alexis: Yeah, look, you've got some talent, that's for sure. But here is the problem. You just see 5% of what's out there. What you need is someone plugged in that know your value and the market, and gets your foot in the door. But here is the real question. What do you want?
Popup: Mapping opportunities... [off-the-shelf D3 animation of icons and links in an expanding graph] Curating opportunities... Working on intros...
Alex: I want an AI native company [music] that's small but with a cracked team.
Alexis: And what are we building?
Alex: Infrastructure for robotics. [music] I want to have a hand in designing the future.
Alexis: Let's talk numbers.
Alex: Minimum 0.5%. Post funding. Salary north of [$$$ kaching bell sound censoring actual figure]. Unlimited AI tokens and the ability to build a team around me.
Alexis: Give me 24 hours.
[music] [phone rings, call from Standout]
Alexis: I've got three tailored opportunities for you. All of them want final round.
Alex: Great. Well... Show me the money.
Fake NGMI news show screen with text overlays: NGMI THEME SONG GENERATED BY 11ElevenLabs / "Alexis Aftalion @alexisaftalion | Witold DLC @saas7w / ALEX: "THE DECISION" / NGMI NGMI NGMI NGMI NGMI ...
Announcer: We are live from NGMI. Alex, what is your decision?
Alex: The one on the right, [music]
Alexis: 18 months from IPO.
Announcer: You're surrounded by journals. Hold your position.
Text message from Standout: first day tomorrow
Text message from Standout: go be excellent
Overlay text: Standout. Top talent doesn't apply, top talent gets represented.
Monster truck rally announcer voice: Overnight success.
It didn't exist until you searched for it. Somehow some scam company bought access to Google's autocomplete traffic and figured out that at 16,000 tokens per second they can just squeak by and fill every single search result with slop and then finish generating the (completely nonfunctional) slop sites in the few seconds that the user is looking at "search" results. If you click on the company you think already existed, you'll see that it's completely made-up, it was just made up when you searched for it. Everything's like that now.
Google may be experimenting with replacing all of your received email in GMail with slop fabricated by the highest bidder as well.
+ 10-20 hrs of free sales work
+ 50+ warm first-person leads
+ Repeat: The above turns into more free work
At this rate, they don't even need to hire anyone. These geniuses, morality be damned, have figured out how to have free labor and profit from job applicants!
Free labour ?
Nobody working a few days or even a week is doing anything of value, simply because they cant opossibly understand the big picture if they are working on any large system. THe reality is they are probably contributing something that is broken or will become technical debt very quickly.
They’re doing sales outreach that’s very different.
Pretty sure the staff still need some time to learn what they are selling, otherwise why bother with the charade.
So it was standout: https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/standout, what a shock that combining recruiting & AI leads to some shady tactics. I've been spammed by "agentic recruiters" to my github & linkedin accounts.
Reminds me of cambioml (YC 23), who [allegedly :)] made interviewees pay for cloud tokens then used their solutions, just last year:
https://www.reddit.com/r/devops/comments/1n7cdua/got_a_devop...
Jokes on them because I’ve already learned that almost every recruiter who reaches out on LinkedIn is just indiscriminate automated spam in one form or another. What next, a YC startup promising to get your band a record deal via MySpace?
As a tangent, can any lawyer clarify, is it illegal for a job applicant if you push everything you are asked to do as part of job applications through AI agents and rip off the most valuable parts of the product to make a clone or to sell competitive intelligence. Anyways seems like a cool idea I can pitch to angel investors :)
YIKES
Standout is lacking standup folks.
But this is what most people would call "growth hacking" or whatever, which is "good" and I wouldn't be surprised if these people raised more millions for their gumption.
GGs
Let's see if LinkedIn just bans this company from getting OAuth tokens...
It doesn't look good.
But as they say all publicity...
Sure, until you find yourself in actual jail, that is.
A 3 day unpaid interview process? Heavy shit
Consisting of 10 hour days?! I know the job market is tough but those are bright red flags standout.work are waving.
I'd take 3 days of unpaid work over the 6 rounds of interviewing over a month and a half that I had to do.
The job market just sucks right now.
I like that the OP doesn’t mind not going paid for work they did but does mind not getting paid for work they didn’t do.
Like “If you want to exploit me you’d better make sure that I’m also wasting days at a time!!!!”
i didnt look too hard at their site but isnt the whole idea that an agent looks for work for you while you do other things and the agent sends messages on your behalf?
Your first fail was having LinkedIn. It was all downhill from there.
This isn't a reddit/hacker news topic. This is a police / lawyer one.
It's both.
Someone from YC should promptly and officially post to this discussion that Standout has been kicked out of Y Combinator, and why, as a warning to all other Y Combinator companies and applicants.
And Y Combinator should fully cooperate with all police investigations and lawsuits against Standout, to show they actually don't support Standout's fraudulent crimes and ethical attrocities. Otherwise it looks like Y Combinator actually condones, encourages, and finances this kind of criminal bullshit.
If you read all the comments in the reddit and hn discussions, it's obvious that Y Combinator itself is suffering reputational harm from Standout's actions, so they have a good reason to sue Standout themselves. At the very least they should demand that Standout return all their money, after reimbursing all their victims for their wasted time and damaged reputations.
https://www.reddit.com/r/recruitinghell/comments/1xyr6ml/com...
BigRonnieRon 14h ago
Couldnt care less about the rejection but how is using a candidate’s personal LinkedIn to conduct business without their permission acceptable?
It may not be. Half of the ycomb startups are run by grifters. A number of them wind up on the fastcompany cover, then jail within 2 years. Fastcompany curse.
You have no concept have many felons and con men run in that crowd. No offense intended to felons for associating them with the hive of scum and villainy that is silicon valley.
BeekeeperZero 14h ago
Grifters is too nice of a description for the majority of ycomb. Narcissistic, entitled, psychopaths would be a bit more spot on.
VisitPier26 13h ago
exactly. people think everyone of these founders is Elizabeth Holmes. The reality is that they may not all be fraudsters, but they are definitely narcissistic hacks.
Might allow others to steer clear of that service/company.
I mean YC runs HN, so it kind of is a HN topic. Hopefully YC does the right thing and investigates and if they did this, kicks them out
What I read the meaning as, is "talk to the poice and a lawyer, it's that serious"
Impersonation is fraud.
Wire fraud no less.
Am curious if that has happened before for anything similar.
I’d be willing to bet they covered themselves in their ToS that were agreed to
Change your password, don't give out your credentials again, and be content that you've learned an important lesson that will make you a better hire for whoever eventually gives you a chance.
They didn't share their password, they "connected [their] LinkedIn". They likely had to accept whatever permission grant the company's app was asking for (which likely included something along the lines of "act on your behalf") but these tend to be extremely coarse to the point that users are used to having to grant broad permissions for trivial legitimate reasons - e.g. every other browser extension asks for permission to "access all websites".
> The ops guy told my account “had remained connected when it should have been removed.”
In other words they have access to an authenticated session. Change your password to have Linkedin revoke other sessions.
I mean this clearly feels like a simple mistake right? I’ve accidentally sent thing from the wrong account on lemlist before
Why did they need the account password in the first place?
I don't think they needed the account password. More likely OP granted some form of access via the LinkedIn API.
Well, same question would apply. Why do they want acces?
Maybe necessary for the unpaid trial work?
> All unpaid of course.
That doesn't seem like a mistake, seems to me like malice.
I remember someone tried to pull this on me, sent a take home assignment that was clearly just a feature they wanted in their software. I called them out on it but said I'd be happy to do it and bill for it. We had a call to chat about it and they outright admitted they were using the take home assignment as free labor.
Apparently they actually did hire someone in the end but, jesus.
Apologize for the mistake and pay for OPs weekend getaway in a 5-star hotel. That's how you move on.
That is nowhere near enough. They damaged their all of their applicants' reputations by spamming many other people with ai slop under the applicants' names.
They owe each an every applicant hard cold cash compensation that they can pay their mortgage and buy food with, not a getaway vacation at a time in their lives when the economy is so totally fucked by Trump's war in Iran, unaffordabl gas and food prices, and financial fallout from tarrifs, while they're out of work, busy looking for a job in a market devistated by ai, and don't have time for a getaway vacation.
And they owe every single other person they spammed under their victims' names a personal apology from THEIR OWN LinkedIn account, taking responsibility and blame for the spam, and explaining that their applicant victims were deceived and did not send that spam. Nothing less is fair to all the victims involved.
And by no means should they move on. They should Standdown not Standout: shut down the company, move back to France with their own reputation in shambles, and never try anything like that ever again. Pick another company? Sheeeeeit, they'd better pick another industry instead. There is no moving on from what they did.